Case 38: This patient led an exemplary life for ten years and became an ardent temperance worker. His wife died, and two years afterwards he married, most unwisely, a young and frivolous girl. Disappointment broke his heart, and he practically committed suicide within three months of his marriage by shutting himself up in his room with a supply of spirits and drinking himself to death. This history shows how impossible it is to affirm that any drunkard is cured until he has died. ' Call no man happy until he is dead,' said Solon.

Cases 46 and 65 are keeping well, according to latest reports (1904-5).

Several of the failures here recorded have tried Keeley and other drug treatments, but in no case, as far as I have learnt, have they been permanently successful. In only one later case (that of a children's nurse sent to me in 1901) has a secret drug treatment been successful when hypnotism failed. This patient was a very good subject, but always expressed great fear of the process. She remained an abstainer for fourteen months after her first hypnotic treatment, and then had a relapse. I treated her again, and she remained sober for three months. Then she relapsed, and further treatment was a failure. It remains to be seen whether the drug treatment makes a better record in the end.

Case.

Sex.

Date.

Age.

Condition.

Nature of Surroundings.

Duration of Habit

Degree of Hypnosis.

Result.

1

M.

Dec. 1888

43

Married, ex-captain

Favourable

3 years

3rd

Cure. No relapse

2

M.

Jan., 1889

34

Married, merchant

Favourable

3 years

2nd

Cure. One relapse in June, 1889

3

M.

Feb., 1890

30

Married,clerk in S.Africa

Unfavourable

2 years

4 th

Relapse after 15 months

4

M.

Feb., 1890

35

Single, ex-officer

Unfavourable

17 years

6th

Cure. No relapse

5

M.

Feb., 1890

45

Married, artist

Unfavourable

Over 10 years

4th

Much benefited. Occasional outbreaks

6

M.

Mar., 1890

34

Married, country gentleman

Favourable (H)

7 years

3rd

Relapse after 7 months, but permanently cured now

7

F.

April, 1890

41

Wife of solicitor

Favourable

Over 5 years

4th

Relapse after temporary benefit

8

F.

May, 1890

40

Single, shop assistant

Unfavourable

Over 10 years

5th

Relapse alter temporary benefit

9

M.

June, 1890

27

Single, tutor

Favourable (H)

3 years

1st

Relapse after temporary benefit

10

M.

June, 1890

60

Married, merchant

Unfavourable

Over 10 years

2nd

No effect

11

F.

Dec, 1890

40

Wife of clergyman

Favourable

7 years

1 St

No effect

12

M.

Dec, 1890

42

Married, clergyman

Unfavourable

Over 10 years

2nd

Relapse after 3 months

13

M.

Feb., 1891

30

Married, merchant

Unfavourable (H)

4 years

6th

Apparently cured, but died after 6 months

14

M.

Mar., 1891

27

Single, country gentleman

Favourable (H)

5 years

3rd

Relapse after 8 months, but permanently benefited

15

F.

Sept., 1891

42

Wife of merchant

Unfavourable (H)

4 years

3rd

Cured

16

F.

Sept., 1891

28

Wife of naval officer

Favourable (H)

5 years

3rd

Much benefited

17

F.

Nov., 1891

32

Wife of clerk

Unfavourable

5 years

6th

Relapse after 3 months

18

F.

Nov., 1891

45

Wife of artisan

Unfavourable (H)

7 years

6th

Relapse after 3 months

19

M.

Nov., 1891

27

Single, surveyor

Favourable

3 years

4th

Relapse after temporary benefit

20

M.

Nov., 1891

36

Married, tradesman

Favourable (H)

7 years

2nd

Relapse after temporary benefit

21

F.

Nov., 1891

37

Married, dressmaker

Unfavourable

7 years

2nd

Relapse after temporary benefit

22

F.

Nov., 1891

24

Wife of clerk

Favourable (H)

3 years

4th

Relapse after temporary benefit

23

F.

Dec, 1891

47

Widow, housekeeper

Unfavourable (H)

7 years

5th

Relapse after 2 years

24

M.

Dec, 1891

54

Widower, gardener

Unfavourable

Over 10 years

6th

Relapse after 3 months

(H) means strongly marked heredity, and that several members of the family have suffered from chronic alcoholism.

Case.

Sex.

Date.

Age.

Condition.

Nature of Surroundings.

Duration of Habit.

Degree of Hypnosis.

Result.

25

M.

Dec, 1891

35

Married, brewer

Unfavourable (H)

7 years

4th

Has had two relapses, but is now doing well since 1 year

26

M.

Dec, 1891

40

Married, chemist

Unfavourable

3 years

5th

Cured

27

M.

Dec, 1891

40

Married, engineer

Unfavourable

4 years

1St

No effect

28

M.

Dec, 1891

32

Married, tutor

Favourable (H)

10 years

3rd

Relapse after 9 months

29

F.

Jan., 1892

43

Widow, servant

Favourable

2 years

5th

Cured. No relapse

30

M.

Jan., 1892

32

Single,country gentleman

Favourable (H)

4 years

3rd

Cured

31

M.

Jan., 1892

35

Married, merchant

Favourable (H)

20 years

4th

Cured

32

M.

June, 1892

40

Lawyer's clerk, single

Favourable

Over 10 years

4th

Several relapses, but has not relapsed now for years

33

F.

July, 1892

35

Cook, single

Favourable

Over 5 years

5th

Temporary improvement, but relapsed after 4 months

34

M.

Nov., 1892

30

Gentleman, single

Favourable

Over 5 years

3rd

No effect

35

F.

Nov., 1892

22

Servant, single

Unfavourable

5 years

5th

Relapse after 2 months

36

M.

Nov., 1892

36

Lawyer, single

Favourable

4 years

3rd

Relapse after 6 months

37

F.

Nov., 1892

35

Housekeeper, single

Favourable

3 years

6th

Relapse after a year

38

M.

Dec, 1892

35

Merchant, married

Favourable

7 years

2nd

Cure. No relapse

39

F.

Dec, 1892

33

Wife of South African merchant

Unfavourable (H)

5 years

6th

Alcohol made her vomit, but she continued to drink, and the treatment had no result

40

M.

Jan., 1893

41

Captain in army, married

Favourable (H)

3 years

3rd

Temporary improvement, but relapse after 7 months

41

M.

Feb., 1893

50

Clerk, married

Favourable

15 years

4th

Relapse after 5 months

42

F.

Feb., 1893

45

Housekeeper, single

Unfavourable

10 years

4th

No effect

43

M.

Mar., 1893

40

Clerk, married

Unfavourable

15 years

4th

Several relapses, but permanently benefited

44

M.

Mar., 1893

45

Butler, married

Unfavourable

10 years

4th

Relapse after 3 months

45

M.

Mar., 1893

30

Gentleman, single

Favourable

10 years

2nd

No effect

(H) means strongly marked heredity, and that several members of the family have suffered from chronic alcoholism.

Case

Sex.

Date.

Age.

Condition.

Nature of Surroundings.

Duration of Habit.

Degree of Hypnosis.

Result.

46

M.

April, 1893

28

Clerk, married

Favourable

5 years

5th

Cured. No relapse

47

F.

June, 1893

35

Servant, married

Favourable

5 years

5th

Relapse after 3 months

48

M.

June, 1893

39

Clerk, single

Unfavourable

10 years

5th

Relapse after 8 months

49

M.

July, 1893

40

Labourer, married

Unfavourable

7 years

4th

Relapse after 4 months

50

M.

July, 1893

45

Engineer, married

Favourable

5 years

4th

Permanently benefited

51

F.

Oct., 1893

44

Wife of chemist

Unfavourable

7 years

6th

Relapse after 2 months

52

F.

Mar., 1894

30

Lady of property, single

Favourable (H)

5 years

6th

Cured. No relapse

53

M.

Mar., 1894

52

Porter, married

Favourable

20 years

4th

Relapse after 2 months

54

F.

April, 1894

47

Wife of gentleman

Unfavourable (H)

5 years

2nd

No effect

55

F.

April, 1894

30

Nurse

Favourable (H)

4 years

6th

She took no alcohol for 2 years; then had a bad relapse. Is now again apparently cured

56

F.

May, 1894

32

Servant, married

Favourable

3 years

6th

Relapse after 3 months

57

M.

July, 1894

45

Shopkeeper, married

Favourable (H)

5 years

3rd

Relapse after 4 months

58

M.

July, 1894

34

Clerk, single

Favourable

4 years

3rd

No effect

59

F.

July, 1894

50

No employment, single

Unfavourable

Over 10 years

5th

No effect

60

M.

Oct., 1894

28

Lawyer's clerk, single

Unfavourable

5 years

3rd

No effect

61

M.

Oct., 1894

50

Gentleman, married

Favourable

15 years

3rd

Permanent improvement, but occasional relapses

62

F.

Jan., 1895

55

Wife of gentleman

Favourable (II)

12 years

1st

Permanent improvement, but occasional relapses

63

F.

Feb., 1895

50

Lady of property, single

Favourable

3 years

3rd

Cured. No relapse

64

M.

April, 1895

41

Gentleman, married

Unfavourable (H)

10 years

3rd

Occasional relapses, but general improvement

65

M.

April, 1895

42

Clerk, married

Favourable

2 years

4th

Cured. No relapse

(H) means strongly marked heredity, and that several members of the family have suffered from chronic alcoholism.

Analysis: 65 cases; 39 men, 26 women. Cured, 15; relapsed after apparent cure of 2 years, 2. Died 6 months after apparent cure, 1. Much benefited permanently, 7; relapsed after 3 to 6 months, 30. No effect, 10. of his unaided will, these suggestions are all one need make; but if he is a person of very weak character, and is exposed to exceptional temptation, it is well to make the deterrent influence stronger by exciting a feeling of extreme physical repulsion, which can easily be done in the case of somnambulists. One has only to tell the patient that if he takes beer or spirits they will at once cause him to vomit, and then on waking him compel him to drink a glass of beer to produce such an attack of nausea and sickness as he will remember for many a day. Even in such a case it will, no doubt, be possible for the subject to re-educate himself to like liquor, just as a schoolboy who will go on smoking, though every pipe at first makes him sick, may at last overcome the repugnance and become a confirmed smoker.*

In the combination of moral and physical influences thus produced we possess a very powerful lever. If a man has been made a drunkard through the solicitations of fast companions, his power of resistance is reduced to nil, and the offer of a drink has so often been followed by its absorption, that the sequence of events becomes automatic, an ideo-motor reflex action; but let such a man be hypnotized, and in this state be told that alcohol is poison, and that to offer him a drink is to grossly insult him - as in a case of a confirmed drunkard reported by Neilson - and we form a new inhibitory tract, which by repeatedly being traversed becomes well worn and habitual in place

* While attending an inebriate patient lately I was visited by an of the other. But it is plain that we must not expect immediate cure. Old channels cannot be destroyed, any more than new ones can be formed, in the course of a few days. I always tell my patients that it takes one month to get over the crude effects of confirmed alcoholism, three months for the liver, stomach, and other organs to recover their tone, and twelve months for the brain power and morale to be re-established.

American physician, Dr. A------, who told me that he had a large practice in the West, and that he was very successful in curing drunkards. My patient was a journalist, aged forty, and as he was a 'soaker' I felt very doubtful about his cure, though he was a somnambulic subject. I asked my visitor to try his hand, so as to reinforce mine, and he kindly complied. His method was to hypnotize him in the usual way, and then make strong anti-alcoholic suggestions. To arouse him he gave him a rather severe blow over the stomach, so that my patient awoke dazed and startled. We were a little disconcerted by this violence, but Dr. A------ assured me he found this method most successful, as the shock drove home the suggestions and fixed them. Unfortunately, however, success in this case was only very short-lived, and the man has since died from the effects of alcohol.

After a period of treatment, varying in different cases, a new personality or ' conscience' is produced, and the patient can return to his former associations and friends so protected as to be safe from relapse. The time necessary for restraint or close observation is from three to six weeks, and after that he should be under observation for at least a year, and the suggestions should be repeated at lengthening intervals during that time. It is by no means necessary that the patient should spend any portion of the time in a retreat if efficient control and observation can be exercised by a trustworthy relation, friend, or attendant. We must remember that at first every public-house offers a suggestion to drink, and every boon companion calls up associations of ideas connected with former self-indulgence, and opposed to the suggestions we have endeavoured to implant.

I was recently induced to undertake the case of a medical man, whose surroundings were extremely unsatisfactory, but the patient expressed a great desire to be cured, and proved a very susceptible subject. Dipsomaniacs are notoriously untrustworthy, and in a few days I found on inquiry that his protestations were false, and that he had made no attempt to avoid temptation, but rather put himself in its way. Under such circumstances the treatment had not a chance, and as he refused to submit to restraint we at once abandoned it.