If a patient should take it into her head to imagine that one was having an undue personal influence over her, as in the case referred to on p. 121, the course to adopt is plain. The physician should decline to operate again, and if the idea persists, he should obtain the assistance of a colleague, whom he should get to hypnotize the patient for him, and to suggest to her the disappearance of the delusion. I have found it necessary to act thus in one case, and the plan was completely successful. The patient, a highly hysterical lady of a certain age, and unmarried, developed a craving for hypnotism in much the same way as she might have for alcohol or morphia.†

* Quoted in Brain, April, 1891.

† Every form of treatment is liable to abuse. I have seen two striking examples of this in Weir-Mitchell cases. The rest and frequent feeding proved so agreeable to the patients that they continued this part of the treatment when they returned to their homes.

The first of these patients was a middle-aged clergyman, who became neurasthenic after an attack of influenza. After he left the nursing-home, he made his wife continue to feed him every four hours, and used to lie in bed all the time, except for a few hours on Sunday, when he got up and conducted service in his church. He came to me for hypnotic treatment, weighing 20 stone, and in a curious apathetic state. I succeeded in stirring him up and making him change his habits. He had been an extremely active and zealous missionary clergyman, so one had good material at bottom to work

There is another reason for the careful regulation of the use of hypnotism which should appeal to all those who have the progress of science at heart. The process of hypnotizing an ordinary subject is so simple that it seems absurd to talk of teaching it to a person of ordinary intelligence and liberal education; to see it done a few-times is to be able to do it one's self. Of course, this is the least part of the treatment, and, in fact, it bears the same relation to the Nancy method as the administration of chloroform does to a subsequent surgical operation. The practice of hypnotic suggestion is surrounded by pitfalls which only the operator with a medical training can avoid, and the results of the treatment are only of scientific value if they have been checked by investigators accustomed to gauge the value of evidence. At the present time, when the treatment is, we may say, in its infancy, we want every fact scientifically investigated, and therefore it is of great importance to restrict the medical use of hypnotism to qualified medical men. * If Dr. Elliotson, a physician of rare ability, and a man of unimpeachable probity, had acted with the discretion shown by Bernheim and other foreign physicians, he would probably have arrived at the truth which it required another generation to extract from a mass of superincumbent rubbish.

There is another danger from the ignorant use of hypnotism as a remedial agent. I cannot agree with some writers who seem to contend that pain must not be interfered with, as it is a part of Nature's recuperative proupon. The other case was that of a lady, who, when dismissed from the nursing-home, straightway took to her bed, and got her maid to feed her every two hours. She added excessive drinking to overfeeding, and, as we couldn't get her to change her mode of life, she soon died of cirrhosis of the liver and fatty heart.

Both these patients discontinued one essential detail of Weir-Mitchell's treatment - the massage, which renders it possible for the system to assimilate the large amount of food consumed.

* I allude, of course, to medical hypnotism, with which 1 am chiefly interested. The scientific value of work done by such trained observers as Messrs. Gurney and Myers has been already referred to.

cess. * It is often a danger-signal which should not be neglected, and covering the signal does not do away with the danger it denotes, but one need not go on waving it indefinitely. I have heard of a patient suffering from gastric ulcer being told by an ignorant magnetizer that she was to go home and eat a beefsteak, and a man with mitral disease directed to run up to the top of a high house. So great is the power of suggestion, that in both these cases the order was obeyed, and the symptoms were masked for a time. One can sometimes remove the effect without touching the cause. But this is true of all 'symptomatic treatment.

i Some persons, especially some young women, are so susceptible that one has only to get their consent and to bid them go to sleep to induce a condition of profound somnambulism. In such cases 'expectant attention' alone seems sufficient, and it is matter for surprise that we do not find more people falling into spontaneous somnambulism, as the condition is so easily induced.

It is these subjects of unstable cerebral equilibrium who are most liable to danger from the abuse of hypnotism, land it is these, consequently, that we should especially 'seek to protect. I need hardly say that the use of hypnotism towards the accomplishment of a crime or misde-meanour should be regarded as a serious aggravation of the offence.

Charcot in France, Ladame in Switzerland, and Semal in Belgium, have done much to stop the public exhibition of hypnotism in those countries, by demonstrating the physical and mental evils which have befallen the subjects of such performances. Those who witnessed a so-called entertainment of this kind given in London some years since must remember how fatigued and languid, or excited and hysterical, were many of the subjects. The aim of a public entertainer is to excite wonder or mirth in the minds of his audience, and so long as he can evoke a sufficiently startling note, he cares little, even if he fully understands, that the instrument he plays upon is the delicate organism of the higher brain centres.*

* Vide article by Dr. Sinclair Thomson in the Westminster Review, December, 1890.