A sad case which took place in Hungary in 1894 seems to belong to this category. A magnetizer, believing in telepathy, who bad not been medically trained, had repeatedly hypnotized a girl suffering from hysteria, whose general health was very bad, and who showed severe nervous disturbances. He had succeeded in improving her considerably. This extremely suggestible girl, who was supposed to be a clairvoyante, was then hypnotized. She was to diagnose the disease of a certain man at a distance, and to determine the condition of his lung. While in the condition of hypnosis, obviously picturing a diseased lung to herself, she began to speak about it, and then suddenly fell back dead. The autopsy only revealed anaemia and beginning oedema of the brain, which does not offer any explanation for the death. Could the terrifying conception of a diseased lung, which the somnambulist might possibly have for the moment thought was her own, have caused her death? Was it accidental? I believe, with Liebault and Bernheim, that the former is possible. One only learned of the case through the daily papers, although many details were given. Anyway, the ease is of much importance.

One of the most peculiar and at the same time most important, if not actually the most important forensic aspect of suggestion, is to be found in the unconsciously produced - i.e., suggested - falsification of memory (hallucination retroactive of Bernheim) by a counsel when cross-examining the accused. I have already discussed this phenomenon. Just as one can wring a confession out of a child, a woman, or a weak man, of a suspicious deed by the power of skillful persuasion, so one can suddenly produce the suggestion in an innocent person that he is guilty. When this takes place, not only a complete confession of the crime, which he has not committed, is made, but all sorts of details of the most concrete kind, as we have seen, are also hallucinated retroactively. It is just these details which serve best to show that one is dealing with a suggested falsification of memory, especially when they do not coincide with the actual facts which can be ascertained about the deed. An easy and very commendable control of experiment, when one is suspicious about this, consists in further suggesting to the accused details which one is quite sure cannot possibly have taken place. If he admits them as well, one can be tolerably certain that the whole confession was valueless - i.e., depended on the suggestion of the barrister. One can prevent horrible legal murders in this way. I have come across a few such eases, and am convinced that they are at times erroneously mistaken for melancholia by asylum doctors, since similar false self-accusations occur in melancholia. We have also seen that certain "instinct liars" are only persons who are so suggestible that they constantly confuse their own conceptions and those conveyed to them by others with reality.

But not only false confessions, but also false witnesses, may be prepared in this manner. In the terrifying procedures which witnesses frequently are subjected to, and in the manner in which they are turned and twisted by the barristers, they will certainly often be induced to make statements which depend on suggestion. Bernheim and I are at one in this. The contradictions which one accuses them of are not always conscious lies: they are not seldom the results of suggestion. It is especially children who are dangerous in this respect, and the younger they are the more marked this is.

One must differentiate two classes of cases - (1) the case in which the suggestion calls forth its effects through the special action on the part of the inquisitor in a person who is otherwise inclined to speak the truth; and (2) the case in which the witness has always confused truth and imagination, because he has never been able to do otherwise.

The second case has been long recognized under all sorts of names, and is of secondary importance. One soon recognizes the type of such witnesses by their behavior in dealing with other things as well, or one learns of it by their reputation. They are regarded as habitual liars, and no weight is attached to their statements. On the other hand, the first case must exercise the mind of the criminal lawyer greatly, for it can occur in really good persons, who bear evidence in all other respects in accordance with the truth, and have only arrived at a false recollection by suggestion. Of course, transition forms frequently occur also in this case.

Is a hypnotized person to be regarded under all circumstances as irresponsible? This question must be regarded in the concrete case as an extremely difficult, almost insoluble, one, after what has been said. As nearly all authors, including von Lilienthal, have done, one must naturally regard every person whose actions are completely governed by the influence of a suggestion as being irresponsible on principle. The hypnotist is responsible for bis actions, for be has made use of them. But how are we going to carry this out in practice, when we think of the frequency of unconscious suggestions, which are not recognized as such, which occur all over the world without tangible hypnosis? Where are we to place the limits of responsibility in the concrete case in the finer shades of waking suggestion which I have already discussed? Natura won facit solium. This old truth is applicable in this case also, and it gives the lie direct to our artificial categories, as it does in mental diseases.

As the authors, and also von Lilienthal, have already pointed out, a further great danger of suggestion lies in the employment of the same by the hypnotized person for the purpose of extortions of all kinds. This danger is so great that the presence of witnesses is more necessary in the interest of the hypnotist than of the hypnotized person. For further particulars I refer the reader to von Lilienthal's essay. The exigency of a person wishing to be hypnotized with the express purpose of having courage or getting off scot-free in connection with a crime suggested to him is also dealt with in the same article. Courage is sought in the cup by some people.

It is scarcely necessary to mention that I am in complete concord with von Lilienthal when he states that public exhibitions of hypnotized somnambulists ought to be rigidly prohibited, on the ground that they represent a gross nuisance which is detrimental to public morals and public health. Such exhibitions may be compared with those of the insane or of physiological experiments. To my mind, the carrying out of hypnosis for gain should be prohibited altogether.

Finally, it appears to me that a frivolous or negligent use of suggestion, and especially an abuse of the same for egotistical purposes, even if they be not criminal, ought not to be neglected in jurisprudence.

Casuistic

In one case an elderly, ugly female spiritualist succeeded in hypnotizing a rich young man to such an extent that he became entirely subjected to her influence, broke off from his relatives, who were very fond of him, and married the old witch. The latter was wise enough and tricky enough to keep him under her influence by her mental accomplishments and by means of sexual stimulation. Such-like and similar cases, in which one of the two sexes takes the active and the other the passive part, have undoubtedly always taken place. It might be desirable if definite legal measures could be adopted in these cases.

Another man told me himself that he had been influenced in a similar way for a time by a woman who had always magnetized him. She was skilled in hypnotizing and was nymphomaniacal-polyandrical as well. This man succeeded only with great difficulty in escaping from the clutches of this woman when she directed her attacks toward other members of his family.

In the Czynski case, on the contrary, the man had the active part In these cases the passive party complains, as we have seen, of feeling the compelling influence; he becomes sexually stimulated. There is no question of a normal love, or even of a normal sexual attraction, but the feeling of impulsion and want of freedom reign supreme. The influenced person would like to escape, but cannot, even though the compulsion does not attain the brutal character of the well-known case of the criminal beggar Castellan, cited by Bernheim and others, who hypnotized a poor girl, took advantage of her, and compelled her to follow him.