This section is from the book "Hypnotism Or Suggestion And Psychotherapy", by August Forel, Dr. Phil. Et Jur.. Also available from Amazon: Hypnotism; Or, Suggestion and Psychotherapy.
All these brain activities act as antagonists to suggestion. But the worst of all for the suggestion is when a definite antagonist (emotion, conception, impulse of will, or a mixture of these activities) regularly counteracts the suggestion against the conscious will of the hypnotized person. This is the disturbing autosuggestion which not infrequently wins the day, in spite of all the endeavors of the hypnotist and of the best.
intentions of the hypnotized. One is much more likely to gain the upper hand over several autosuggestions (by means of the divide et impera) than over one of them alone.
One observes a variety of things on carrying out hypnotic experiments in the insane. In acute psychoses emotions oppose us, and the power and duration of these stifle everything else. I have often attempted to hypnotize away simple homesickness in the healthy. This only succeeds with difficulty, and sometimes fails. Even in this case the emotional wave, and the conception associated with it, form an almost insurmountable antagonist. The hypnosis may succeed, and even other troubles (pain and the like) may be banished successfully, but it attacks the impulse of homesickness unsuccessfully. How much more markedly is this the case in the psychoses I
As I have already said, one can certainly overcome the initial onset and the early stage of a p9ychosis by suggestion in certain cases. But if a melancholia, a mania, or a delusional insanity has broken out, one will only rarely be able to tran-quilize the patient for the time being. The antagonist in the brain, no matter of what nature it be, is much too powerful. (For further details, see my histories of cases, given later.)
We find that other forms of psychoses, especially those forms with prominent delusions, also act as powerful antagonists, toward which suggestion is helpless. The attempt even to hypnotize a patient suffering from delusions of persecution or delusions of exaltation mostly proves itself to be futile, and may even be a harmful experiment. This patient regards everything with the utmost suspicion which aims at influencing his person in any way. The former suffers from delusions of encroachment, as it were, and applies the most innocent things to himself. Since the invention of the telephone, those suffering from delusions of persecution frequently imagine that they are harassed by secret telephones (air telephones and the like). As hypnotism is discussed everywhere, one often finds the most marked hypnotic delusions of persecution in such patients. They fancy that they are being secretly hypnotized, or that they are being persecuted hypnotically by enemies, and so on. Telepathic and spiritualistic theories form excellent food for this kind of delusion system. One can now understand how foolish it is to wish to hypnotize such patients. One only supplies them with material for delusions, which are at once directed against those hypnotizing. I have only done this once or twice at first, experimenti causa, found my belief that it must be as I have described confirmed, and have then let the matter drop. The patients with delusions of exaltation despise the hypnotist inordinately, and only become excited by the attempt.
Patients suffering from organic psychoses depending on atrophy of the brain cannot, as a rule, grasp a suggestion. The destructive brain process is generalized in such a way that one cannot even obtain those partial results which one often obtains in apoplectic paralysis. The brain tissue of the apoplectic patient is still relatively healthy apart from the affected area, The tissue of a brain in the condition of senile or general paralysis is diseased through and through.
The results in inheritod and constitutional psychoses, in psychopathy, hysteria, etc., are very materially better, provided that well-marked idiocy is excluded. But the cerebral lesion and the morbid disposition naturally cannot be removed. Still, one can obtain much that is for the good of the patient - at all events, in a number of cases - by means of a correct suggestive pedagogic treatment, by introducing the habit of good and healthy activities, by stimulating the healthy traits of character, and by suggesting abhorrence and disgust for morbid and perverse impulses. For this purpose, it is true, the individual concerned must be reasonably suggestible, and must possess some good qualities, which is often the case. The brain in these cases is neither affected by delusions nor continually under the influence of emotions; the dynamic conditions of suggestibility are therefore present,
The same applies to the intoxication psychoses (after the delirium has passed off), in which one can achieve a cure for the rest of life by suggestion of a dislike of the narcotic and of total abstinence from the drug. One cannot arrive at a cura-tivo action in its full sense in certain cases of secondary psychoses which have run their course, hut one attains important impulses toward useful activities - e.g., toward work, etc. - and also inhibition of perverse habits, in place of this. However, these cases are rare, and owe their existence to the cessation of the emotions and of the delusions, together with a partial preservation of the intelligence. Thus, they only help to confirm my view. The majority of persons suffering from secondary insanity are too demented and too confused, and harbor too many delusions, to admit of suggestive influence.
At first sight it appears less easy to explain that certain insane patients can be easily hypnotized, that one can influence them freely as far as pain, appetite, motion of the bowels, menstruation, sleep, and the like, are concerned, although the mental disturbance, the morbid delusions, and emotions, continue to exist unchanged and unshortened. One sometimes observes if one hypnotizes hysterical persons without having determined on a plan of procedure, without a programme, that the patient lapses into a deep lethargic sleep; I have seen this in four patients. In two of these patients, one of which was an hystero-epileptic male and the other an hysterical girl, this deep sleep set in with such lightning rapidity that I failed completely to remain in psychical connection with them. None of the means at my disposal sufficed to make them suggestively obedient. I only succeeded in awakening them from their sleep with great difficulty, although I had found it easy to put them to sleep. They were completely anaesthetic, and the man showed complete relaxation of all muscles, while the girl was cataleptic. In the third case, that of an epileptic boy, the deep sleep also set in suddenly. However, it was always possible, albeit with great difficulty, to obtain some weak actions of suggestion by loud shouting and energetic stirring up. The fourth case was one of melancholic psychopathic disturbance, which became circular later on. This patient lost the "rapport" during the deep lethargic sleep which followed the hypnotizing by a colleague of mine. In this case I was able soon to replace the "rapport" completely after a little practice, and to achieve somnambulic obedience.
I was consulted in an interesting case by my colleague, Dr. Boesch. The patient was an hysterical girl who had lapsed into a spontaneous catalepsy. The extremities were cold and cyanotic, the look was glassy, and the skin was anaesthetic during the ecstatic sleep, with dreamlike hallucinations. I attempted in vain to establish a suggestive "rapport." But certain signs seemed to me to indicate that this was not quite impossible. Boesch attempted, on my advice, to influence the girl after she had awakened from the sleep, which lasted for several hours each day, by means of suggestion during waking. He succeeded in this in so far that he achieved suggestive obedience to a great extent - at first during the waking condition, and, as a result, even in the spontaneous cataleptic sleep. Unfortunately, this influence was lost later on, before it had resulted in a complete cure.
 
Continue to: