This section is from the book "Hypnotism Or Suggestion And Psychotherapy", by August Forel, Dr. Phil. Et Jur.. Also available from Amazon: Hypnotism; Or, Suggestion and Psychotherapy.
One meets at times with acute curable hysteria, following severe emotions (psychical traumata) or wasting illnesses, and also arising without any ascertainable cause, and the patients in these cases have not shown a trace of such phenomena previously. One is apt to regard these cases under the new-fashioned term of "neurasthenia." However, perfectly pure cases of this kind are rare. As a rule, one deals with an acquired pathological hysterical reaction of a person who is at least constitutionally predisposed in these cases, and this can usually be proved by following up the anamnesis carefully. The actual neurasthenias do not fare any better (by this one means hypochrondriasis, other psychopathieal conditions and the like, provided that they are not cases of early general paralysis of the insane). Even these are only rarely the results of mental overwork, but are mostly the results of hereditary predisposition, associated with psychical traumata or exhaustions, and the like. In this way, Beard's " new discovery " resolves itself into a new naming of long-recognized clinical pictures chiefly.
If I might be allowed to draw conclusions from this resume.
which I fear has already become too long, I should choose the following:
1. Hysteria is not a completely circumscribed clinical picture, but is a pathological symptom complex or syndrome.
2. This symptom complex may be constitutional or, more rarely, acquired; both factors are not infrequently combined.
3. This symptom complex is characterized especially by a pathological dissociability (suggestibility and autosuggesti-bility) in which the autosuggestibility preponderates in the severer and more markedly constitutional cases. It is combined under numerous conditions with other phenomena of constitutional psychopathic conditions.
Pathological dissociability corresponds to a condition of the brain in which conceptions, impulses of the will and emotions are especially easily and intensively dissociated. In consequence, spontaneous somnambulic chains, which act intensely, are formed in the contracted consciousness. These chains can carry the personality with them, and may, under certain conditions, divide it into a double "ego"; it then is able to mature some very extraordinary phenomena. The dramatic hysterical deceptions and dreamlike instability, generally speaking, of such patients come under this heading.
The pathological suggestibility and autosuggestibility manifest themselves by the production of manifold functional disturbances of the whole nervous system: psychopetal, psycho-fugal, and psychocentral, through the intermediation of conceptions. These disturbances can produce material changes in the cells, which are easily visible, but which are by no means of more importance than others on this account. It is undoubtedly true that molecular changes of living nerve elements correspond to every function and disturbance of function of the nervous system (Hodge and others). One must regard peripheral hysterical nerve disturbances and changes as products of pathological hysterical suggestions and autosuggestions (anaesthesia, paralysis, contracture, contraction of the field of vision, haemorrhage of the mucous membrane, etc).
If the definition of hysteria as I have given it be accepted, the gradual limitation in all directions, even in the direction of normal suggestibility, becomes self-evident. The difference between hysteria and normal suggestibility may be compared with the difference between melancholia and normal sadness, or between "moral" insanity and normal egotism, or between pathological swindling and normal willful cheating, or also between normal and hypochondriacal sensation of pain.
Very marked suggestibility is already hypernormal, and may at times be accompanied by hysterical predisposition. Still, that which distinguishes hysteria more especially is the pathological reaction, the decking out of the suggestions given with unintentional autosuggestions, and the wholesale production of paralyses, convulsions, pains, etc., which have not been suggested.
Uncorrected hypnosis of the hysterical is quite a different thing to hypnosis of the normal person. Dr. Babinski does not take this fact into consideration. The former overshoots the mark, tends to the production of lethargy or hysterical attack, does not obey the suggestions, or exaggerates them, and must be guided with especial caution, circumspection, and skill; it must, in fact, be normalized.
Hysterical dissociability plays an important part, socially and historically as well as therapeutically. It is especially this which transforms a personalily, be it for good or for bad. When the hysteria occurs in a gifted person he not infrequently becomes a convert, a leader of the mob, a prophet, or the like. But one must not suppose that all enthusiasts and fanatics exhibit hysterical phenomena. One meets with these phenomena in those cases in which striking transformations of the whole personality, caused by suggestion, take place. However, this may also be due to actual psychoses (e.g., paranoia). In this case a degeneration of the "ego" takes place, which is not the case in hysteria.
Meynert said that hypnosis is " an experimentally produced idiocy." If he had said "insanity" his statement would have been more plausible. His views, which are deduced, and which have been thrust upon us without any knowledge of the matter, are obviously based on the fact that one can produce many phenomena (hallucinations, false beliefs, deceptions of memory, and the like) in the hypnotized which are also to be observed in the insane. A casual observer can be easily led astray by these analogies, if he has had no experience of suggestion, but has only gained experience of the insane. The following points are obviously forgotten in connection with this:
1. All these apparent symptoms of mental disturbance occur also in normal sleep, albeit that they are for the most part less well developed (see p. 75). And sleep is certainly not a mental disease.
2. The induced symptoms in hypnotized persons do not exhibit any tendency toward being spontaneously repeated in the waking condition, provided that the operator understands his subject, and does not intentionally endeavor to cultivate and fix the disturbing symptoms by means of suggestions. This brings me to a very important question. Liebeault, Bernheim, Wetterstrand, van Eeden, van Renterghem, de Jong, Vogt, Ringier, Delius, I myself, and the other pupils of the Nancy school, declare emphatically that we have never met with a single case of serious or lasting damage to the mental or bodily health produced by hypnosis, but have observed very many cures and improvements in illnesses in persons whom we have treated. And it must be pointed out that we have had the experience of many thousand cases of hypnotized persons. Autosuggestions and hysterical attacks, transitory mild dizziness in the head, and the like, as well as the occurrence of auto-hypnosis on a few occasions during our early attempts and while we were still wanting in practice, were the only indications of "damage" which have been observed. The matter cannot be dismissed by ambiguous forms of speech, in view of such evidence. Either we are all miserable liars, or the supposititious damage of hypnosis must depend partly on the application of faulty methods, partly on the stupidity of unskilled operators, partly on frivolous experiments, but chiefly on misconceptions and exaggerations. We hold this view. I had the opportunity of witnessing a hypnosis of fright according to the Salpetriere method in Paris in 1889. An assistant advanced toward an hysterical girl. She realized his intention, cried out, and fled into every corner, with the expression of disgust and great fear. In spite of this she was captured, and, heedless of her despairing struggles, was held fast. The assistant then pressed with all his strength on some point or other (shoulder or leg) which is supposed to be a zone hypnogene. The patient was hypnotized suddenly in a cataleptic position in this manner. They did not even take the trouble to quiet her by means of suggestions. We certainly must state that one can do damage in this way, and even without having recourse to such brutal behavior, one may do damage if the patient is frightened instead of being reassured.
 
Continue to: