Hallucination proves that, under certain circumstances, the impressions of memory, and even whole complexes of the same, can be ecphorized again in such a manner, by pure internal stimuli of the brain, that they are in all respects equivalent subjectively to a perception - i.e., to the mentally produced picture of consciousness of a complex of the stimulation of the special senses, actually projected from the periphery. It remains an open question whether the difference between perception and internal conception - e.g., in a dog - depends only on the difference of the intensity of the corresponding cerebral activity, or whether it is explainable by assuming that in hallucination the centripetal cell-fiber columns from the secondary center to the corresponding area of the cortex - e.g., the corpus geniculatmn externum, the visual conduction column to the cuneus for the sense of sight, etc. - are drawn into sympathetic excitement. The last explanation appeals to me as the most likely. It is certain that a blind man, with total destruction of both eyes and total atrophy of both optic nerves and of the optic track, can hallucinate still after many years. But von Monakow has shown that the cells of his corpora geniculata externa must be preserved, since these cells do not atrophy after the enucleation of the eye.

However this may be, the above-mentioned facts prove that not only hallucination or deceptive perception, but also the per-ception caused by real stimulation of the special senses, are in themselves cerebral processes. It is further known that a child at first only receives a medley of impressions through its senses, and must learn to observe, so that the perception depends on coordinating modeling of impressions in the cerebrum.

I considered it necessary to give all these psychological and anatomical explanations, because I have noticed that the want of a correct psychological and anatomical understanding causes the phenomena of hypnotism to appear in the light of a marvel not only to the laity, but also to medical men. The marvel, if there is one, exists in the problem of the genesis of the mind - i.e., of the genesis of the brain - but not in hypnotism, if one accepts the monistic view.

Presuming that an activity produced in the brain of a human being through spoken words takes the form of a complex of energy, 1 such activity manifesting itself in the mirror of consciousness as a complex imagination, one must accept that associated hypoconceived activities cooperate with it. It is comparatively immaterial whether the given conception is ascer-tainably accompanied by the reflection of the superconscious-ness or not. If the speaker succeeds in mastering the course of the conception in others by means of intentional, rapid, and concentrated action, accomplished by tone, words, looks, etc., he becomes increasingly capable of associating or dissociating.

1 Such complexes of energy consist of two groups of factors: the inherited (inherited rnneme)and the acquired (acquired engrams of the brain of the individual). Both groups of factors combine in a manifold manner in each individual case (single observation). I refer the reader to Semon's book on the Mneme (tec. cil.), and to my "Sexual Question" (Rebman Company, New York).

The brain activity of the influenced person will thus become more plastic and more adaptable toward him.

He succeeds thus in producing inhibitions and conductions, which can lead to hallucination, to the cutting off of the various linkings of the consciousness from one another (and thus to regular amnesia), to the stimulation and inhibition of the voluntary movements, to the stimulation and inhibition of the vasomotor functions (influence on menstrual and other bleeding), and even to the influencing of secretory and trophic nerve functions (sweating, vesication), according to the degree of the attained influence. All this is explainable by the peculiarity of the nerve activity, and especially of the cerebral activity. Miracles, superstition, bewitching, the belief in the mysterious, and the belief in spirits are robbed to a great extent of their halo by this, on the whole, comparatively simple elucidation, and are explained naturally.

I will illustrate the insufficiency of our pure psychology by one example. What a confusion is caused by the words "seeing" and "willing"! Does the pigeon whose brain has been removed see or not? As a matter of fact, there are several degrees of "seeing."

1. The elementary amoeboid "sight" of the retinal elements, which is closely related to the photodermic sensations (light appreciation of the skin) of the lower animals. This sight cannot be considered as optic, since an element cannot perceive an optical image.

2. The sight of the anterior pair of the corpora quadrigemina and of the external geniculate body (the secondary optic centers), which receive a collected coordinate transmission of the collected retinal impression through the optic nerve. This is the Bight of the brainless pigeon. This lower form of sight is never conceived by us human beings. It may be regarded as being optical, but is practically analogous to the sight of the insects which do not possess a cerebrum - e.g., ants - and is scarcely capable of using optic impressions of memory in association.1

3. The sight of the so-ealled visual sphere of the cortex (cuneus), which, in spite of the physiologist Golz, do exist, 1 Ford, "The Psychical Capabilities of Ants' (Munchen: E. Rheinhardt, 1901).

Since the fiber system from the subcortical centers ends in this place (Monakow). This corresponds to our usual super- and hypo-conscious human sight. The visual sphere receives the retinal impression second-hand, if one may use this term, and combined with many complicated associations.

4. There is still one other sight, a mental vision - viz., the repercussion of these optical stimuli of the visual sphere in other associated areas of the cortex of the cerebrum. There are people who are able to see sounds colored (Nussbaumer, Bleuler, and Lehmann), inasmuch as they always associate certain colors (mostly the same) with certain sounds or vowels.

The same applies to the centrifugal or voluntary activity, from the conceived wish, through resolve and action, to impulse and reflex twitching. This is nothing else than the completed result of feelings and of the intellect elements associated with them, however much movement may act furtheringly on impressions and feelings. The study of the disturbances of speech demonstrates plainly that there is no boundary between "somatically" and "psychically" produced motor complexes of innervation and disturbances of the same.

If we consider all these facts with that which has been stated in the early pages, we shall no longer be astonished so very much by the seeming contradictions and mysteries of hypnotism. We shall be able more readily to understand that a hypnotized person sees, and yet does not see; believes, and yet frequently apparently simulates with a certain complaisance. His consciousness can believe, and, for example, in reply to a negative hallucination, not see and not hear; while outside the reflection of consciousness, which ha3 been dimly blotted out like a breath of air, the rest of his brain activity (his hypo-consciousness, as we have already called it) sees clearly, hears clearly, and gets out of the way of the obstruction. But in another case a concentrated powerful suggestion action may grasp much more profoundly into the hypoconceived brain activity, and may even, having been conducted strongly along the peripheral nerves, react on these, as we can see in the inhibition and production of menstruation, for example, or in the production of diarrhoea and blisters on the epidermis.