Both Wetterstrand 1 and Bernheim emphasize that one is apt greatly to undervalue the palliative action of suggestion in producing sleep and in quieting pain in severe incurable diseases, such as tuberculosis, cancer, etc. I would wish to add that one underestimates very vastly its enormous value in everyday medicine as an aperient, as a means of procuring appetite and sleep, and as a regulator of digestion, secretion, and menstruation.

It is invaluable in these conditions, and is quite harmless, in contradistinction to the scandalous abuse which so many practitioners make of narcotics and alcohol. One can produce sleep even in high fever by suggestion.

Ringier 2 has divided the two hundred and ten cases which be has treated into the following groups:

1. Dynamic neuroses, of a motor, vasomotor, and secretory nature.

2. Dynamic sensory neuroses, neuralgias.

3. Sleeplessness.

4. General cerebral neuroses (or mild psychoses).

5. Rheumatic affections.

6. Intoxications.

7. Various cases. Of these:

Cases

(1)

Cured, with a report later that the cure had lasted .............................

73

(2)

Cured, without a subsequent report..............

15

(3)

Considerably improved, with or without subsequent report................

64

(4)

Somewhat improved, with or without subsequent report..................

19

(5)

Failure of the hypnosis, or not improved.............

25

(6)

Interruption of treatment, mostly early............

12

(7)

Hypnosis for surgical cases.................

2

Total......................

210

1 Wetterstrand, "Hypnotism and its Application in Practical Medicine." (Vienna: Urban and Schwarzenberg, 1891.)

2 Ringier, "Results of Therapeutic Hypnotism in Country Practice." (Munchen: Lehmann, 1891.)

Ringier complains with justification about the unsatisfactory results of the frequent early interruption of the treatment in country practice. The majority of the improved would have undoubtedly been cured if they had persevered.

Among the number of interesting tables, the following deserve special notice: twenty-seven recurrences among the considerably improved, nine recurrences among the slightly improved, bo that he had thirty-six recurrences, all of which belong to the patients who were only improved.

Degree

Cure with subsequent

Report

Cure without report

Considerrable Improvement

Slight Improvement

Failure

Percent.

Percent.

Percent.

Percent.

Per cent.

Somnolence.............

18.75

.............

6.25

6.25

43.75

Hypotaxis..........

24.45

8.62

31.89

14.21

12.07

Somnambulism and deep sleep.......................

48.05

5.19

33.76

6.49

5.19

Of two hundred and nine hypnotized persons (in one case there are no details on these points), sixteen fell into the condition of somnolence, one hundred and sixteen fell into the condition of hypotaxis, and seventy-seven fell into the condition of somnambulism or deep sleep.

In addition to this, Ringier met with twelve completely refractory persons out of a total of two hundred and twenty-one; in these a suggestive treatment could not be undertaken on this account.

The results, expressed in percentages, work out as follows:

Refractory....................................

5.43

Somnolence ........................

7.24

Hypotaxis......................

52.49

Somnambulism and deep sleep................

34.84

The duration of the treatment, expressed in the number of sittings, is given as follows:

In 94 cases only 1 sitting " 43 " " 2 sittings " 23 " " 3 " " 12 " " 4 "

In

4

cases

only

5

sittings

"

8

"

"

6

"

"

1

case

"

7

"

"

4

cases

8

"

"

21

"

more

than 8 sittings

Of the last-named, one ease was treated in thirty-five sittings, one in twenty-one, and one in twenty, while all the rest were treated in less than twenty sittings.

These tables disprove most conclusively the contention of our adversaries who try to compare suggestive therapy with the morphine habit.

The above are only a few summary extracts of some of the many tables which Dr. Ringier has compiled with the utmost statistical exactness from all points of view, and which show the matter in a critical light. His chief aim was to adhere strictly to objective observation, and not to allow his results to appear too favorable. These results confirm those of his predecessors and mine.

I used to teach suggestive therapy in my out-patient class for medical students in Zurich every Saturday from 2 :30 to 4. The patients were derived from the town. I first examined them, and then, imitating Wetterstrand's example, made them all sit in armchairs in the presence of the students. I began with those who had already been hypnotized previously, and thus I saved myself from having to prepare the new patients. When the new patients' turns arrived, they were, as a rule, already so much influenced that they fell asleep at once. Like Bernheim, I explained to the apparently refractory patients that they were already influenced, and that sleep was not necessary in their cases. I then employed amulets, pieces of metal, and the like at times, together with suggested currents; in this way nearly all of them became hypnotized after one or two sittings (some of them, I must admit, however, only became hypotactic). I have not prepared a statement of the cases and results, on account of want of time, although I obtained very good therapeutic results. I may point out that these results were obtained in this simple way in spite of the disturbing presence of the students (many of the patients were embarrassed by this), in spite of the fact that I only hypnotized once a week (sometimes twice in the more difficult cases), and in spite of the necessity of giving the suggestions aloud for teaching purposes, as well as in spite of the unsuitable quality of the cases.