I lay great stress on this procedure. I am absolutely convinced that want of knowledge of this or ignoring it is responsible for the unintentional damages ascribed to hypnosis of which we read in the literature on the subject. I have personally seen a case of trembling and pain in an arm which was produced by this sort of unskillful hypnotizing on the part of an inexperienced young man; it lasted for a few months, but was then completely removed again by suggestion.

In my experience, one achieves more, as a rule, with hysterics by skillfully applied suggestions during waking than one does by means of formal (announced) hypnosis. The old rule remains the same: kind, consistent, and firm. One must gain the sympathy of the hysterical person, and at the same time require respect from him. One must never scoff at him, or show him any mistrust, repulsion, or contempt, or else one will damage him considerably. But one must be just as careful not to spoil him, and not to attach much importance to his attacks, pains, etc. One speaks confidently of cure, insists that he will obey implicitly, and then one guides him imperceptibly, by tickling his ambition, etc., into an occupied mode of living, and into healthy hygienic habits by giving him therapeutic hygienic suggestions whenever one comes into contact with him. One should employ medicaments as seldom as possible, and never have recourse to narcotics. I wish to deduce the maxim from all these facts that medical practitioners who are still inexperienced in dealing with suggestions, and especially young practitioners who so far have had but little general experience, should avoid attempting their first hypnotic experiments on hysterical persons.

That one can do harm by suggestion, if one wishes to, is obvious, and is only the reverse of the curative action of suggestion. One can suggest headache, disturbances of menstruation, etc., just as well as one can suggest them away. But if one wishes only to do good, one must never speak to a hypnotized person of the possibility of doing harm, and, on the contrary, always state firmly and unconditionally that suggestion can only act for good. In this way one removes the harmful autosuggestions in the best manner, and preserves a healthy suggestive atmosphere around the patient.

One must avoid the "occurrence of self-hypnosis," the supposed "weakening of the will-power," and other things of this kind, by the same means of counter-suggestion. The danger of these things are always being held up as arguments against therapeutic hypnotism. Only on one occasion, while I was still a beginner, did a person whom I had hypnotized fall into a hypnotic sleep of his own account. He received such an energetic suggestive lecture from me in return that the affair was not repeated. If one admits the right of existence of such phenomena in one's environments, they will Boon be repeated, not only in the same patient {as, for example, in the hypnotized hysterical girl of von Krafft-Ebhing), but also in others. This can be seen in Dr. Friedrich's results, 1 who hypnotized by false methods and with preconceived notions. But, on the other hand, a self-hypnosis suggested by means of an amulet is not dangerous. However, one must limit the duration of this to a few minutes by means of suggestion, and only allow it to take place through the intermediation of the amulet and for definite treatment purposes, with the permission of the doctor.

One must always suggest perfect health, cheerful mood, good sleep, good appetite, and strengthening of the will. Besides this, one should always bear in mind Bernheim's and Liebeault's rules:

1. To insist on having at least one suitable witness for every hypnotizing, as a protection for the hypnotist as well as for the person hypnotized. 2

1 Doctor Friedrich, "Annals of the General Hospital in the Town of Mun-chen," 1894. The article of Doctor Friedrich, which is directed against the therapeutic application of hypnotism, proves conclusitely that the author has fallen into all the errors which one should avoid, and that he has completely misunderstood the whole Question.

2 Special exceptions in which absolute mutual trust can be relied on may take place under especial conditions.

2. To give the suggestion to all very suggestible persons (somnambulists) that no one else can hypnotize them.

3. Not to hypnotize any one without first obtaining his spoken permission.

4. Only to give suggestions for therapeutic purposes, as long as legal, scientific, or didactic purposes do not enter into the question.

I have called attention to many baneful suggestions which are exercised unconsciously by medical practitioners by their expressions of face, by their examinations and prognoses. 1 Bernheim has also done the same. I am fully aware that I once suggested a gastric ulcer to a patient in whom I suspected this condition by having a serious countenance, and by carefully palpating the region of the stomach, and ordering rest in bed and milk diet. I suggested the site of the pain by means of a pointed question, and the result of my want of knowledge of suggestion at the time was that the patient was confined to her bed for many months of a suggested illness which was not really present. The patient proved herself later on to be an excellent somnambulist. Hysterical cough, hysterical attacks, diseases of the stomach, uterine disturbances, constipation, and nervous disorders of all kinds are frequently suggested in this manner by anxious practitioners, who are apt to take serious views of cases, or are autosuggested by the patients themselves. There is no doubt as to the truth of this.

That one can suggest hysterical attacks, for example, even without using words, by means of unskillful manipulations has long been recognized. We have all reported this, and it has been confirmed by Dr. Friedrich in a striking manner. But when one understands suggestion, one gets accustomed, not to produce it, but to remove it.