This section is from the book "Hypnotism Or Suggestion And Psychotherapy", by August Forel, Dr. Phil. Et Jur.. Also available from Amazon: Hypnotism; Or, Suggestion and Psychotherapy.
Lloyd Tuckey1 and Hirt recommend suggestion in the treatment of alcoholism. I must caution against a crass misunderstanding in this place. It is an absolutely idiotic and harmful undertaking to try to convert a "soaker" into a moderate drinker by means of suggestion, as Hirt advises. One sins against the First Commandment for a lasting result of the suggestion therapy, by allowing the damaging cause of the illness to persist after the result. There are, it is true, no rules without exceptions, and it is possible that in rare cases a not consummate drinker may be rendered moderate in this way, provided that he has been led to abuse alcohol as a result of definite circumstances, and not from hereditary causes nor from psychopathic conditions. But in the large majority of cases one will experience relapses sooner or later, on account of the contra-suggestion induced by the enjoyment of alcohol and by being "sociable." I have observed this repeatedly in drunkards, who attempt to begin again to drink moderately. The majority of drunkards are, besides, individually predisposed, and boeome incapable of resisting alcohol from habit. If suggestion is, therefore, to be of real use in the treatment of alcoholism, one must suggest definite and complete abhorrence of all spirituous liquors, lifelong total abstinence from the same, and, if possible, the joining a temperance society. Tuckey agrees with me in this respect; and the secret of the renowned and costly "gold cure" of alcoholics by Keeley is undoubtedly to be found in this idea. Keeloy did not suggest moderation for his patients; he suggested complete abhorrence for all spirituous liquors.
1Lloyd Tuckey, "The Value of Hypnotism in Chronic Alcoholism." (London: Churchill, 1892.)
One does the same in the treatment of the morphine habit, except for the belonging to a society. But there is no tempting sociability, no compulsion to drink in company for the morphine-takers, as there is for alcoholists. For this reason the suggestive sociability of the temperance society, which is devoid of alcohol, is so important for the latter.
I myself have converted many a drunkard to abstinence by means of suggestion. Still, as Bonne 1 has justly said, the abstaining medical practitioner suggests infinitely better, since his example and his inward conviction assist the suggestion. I have shown the good results statistically of suggestion in alcoholism as long ago as in 1888. 2
1Bonne, Wien. Med. Presse, No. 45. 1901. 2Fowl, Munch. Med. Woch., No. 26, 1888.
 
Continue to: