This section is from the book "Hypnotism Or Suggestion And Psychotherapy", by August Forel, Dr. Phil. Et Jur.. Also available from Amazon: Hypnotism; Or, Suggestion and Psychotherapy.
The cure has been maintained. A recurrence of the rheumatism, which took place two years previously, had been cured in two sittings. The preparations for a big operation (rectal carcinoma) in hospital had upset him to such an extent that hypnosis became impossible. Chloroform had therefore to be used. He recovered from the operation, but a recurrence took place later. A second operation, for which the preparations were not perceptible, was successfully performed under hypnosis without chloroform. He died after this operation.
3. Miss L., a very capable workgirl, had suffered for about one and a half years from complete sleeplessness. All means had been tried unsuccessfully, and she was sensible enough to resist the temptation of accustoming herself to narcotics. She was handed over to me by one of my colleagues for out-patient treatment as a subject for demonstration in February, 1890,
Several hypnotic sittings were necessary to obtain a marked degree of hypnosis gradually, and to realize various suggestions. At first it was only in my presence that I succeeded in getting her to steep spontaneously on taking a drink of water. I let her sleep for a considerable time (one hour), and in this way I was able to restore the normal night sleep thoroughly after about three weeks (from 9 p.m. till 6 a.m.). She was then discharged cured.
Early in January of 1891 she came to me of her own account, looking exceptionally well, to thank me, and to tell me how happy she was to be completely cured of her insomnia, and to have remained fit for work. She bad suffered from a severe attack of typhoid fever in the summer of 1890, which was accompanied by high fever, and in which she had several relapses; she bad almost been "given up" during this illness. She had again become sleepless during the fever, it is true, but normal good sleep bad returned spontaneously in her convalescence. I mention this case especially for the benefit of those who argue that one only drives out the devil by Beelzebub when one substitutes hypnotic treatment for morphine treatment. These gentlemen can thus be shown that the analogy is inapplicable from two points of view, for neither an intoxication nor a habit is produced by suggestive treatment, and one simply restores the natural healthy sleep. However, "II n'y a pire sourde que celui qui ne veut pas entendre." And therefore examples may be useful. Since then I have treated many similar cases with equally good results; three of these came under my care in the summer of 1905.
4. Mrs. F., a spontaneous somnambulist, born in 1833, had followed the calling of a fortune-teller since her fifteenth year. She had been punished by law in Germany for alleged swindling. She was married, and had a big family. One of her labors had taken place while she was in a somnambulic condi-tion, and she had not felt anything of what was going on. She only awoke after the baby wa3 born.
She had consultation hours, and the patients flocked to her. Since her youth she had fallen to sleep suddenly and spontaneously every day at nine and three o'clock, generally with a cry. The sleep lasted from a quarter to three-quarters of an hour, according to the number of patients who came to Bee her. During the sleep she spoke in a pathetic tone of voice. It is not she who speaks, but it is " the spirit of Ernest," which haunts her, and who lies buried in Basle. She was accused of deception on these grounds, and was sent to me in order that I might examine her.
I succeeded at once in placing her, during her spontaneous somnambulic sleep, by means of suggestion, under my control and under the influence of my suggestion. She was forced to obey the suggestions even post-hypnotically, in spite of the resistance of "the spirit of Ernest." She became anaesthetic. The reality of the somnambulism was undoubted; her physiognomy was completely transformed, and she was totally amnesic after awakening. I succeeded in hypnotizing her whenever I wished, and in removing the spontancous attacks. Before this, experiments were carried out during one of these attacks. Patients suffering from maladies the nature of which was well known to us were shown to her, and she was required to make a diagnosis and to determine the treatment. She spoke pathetically to the patients, calling them " my dear," and touched them with her hand, keeping her eyes closed. Her diagnoses were all wrong, for we avoided any words or signs which might have put her on the right track. Then Dr. Mercier, the second assistant, came into the room pretending to be lame, and allowed her to examine him. She diagnosed a "disease of the legs" (which was not present). It thus became clear that her diagnoses were based on the action of suggestion, produced by the phenomena in the patients, which she recognized by her senses. There was not a suspicion of clairvoyance to be detected. She knew how to gain pecuniary advantage out of everything, just as the majority of normal people do, and as many superstitious persons and even some insane persons also do. Still, it is a great mistake which the simulation theory makes to deduce from this that it was all simulation. It is well known that suggestions which are desired readily gain the upper hand over those which are not wanted. It is true that she stated that she would be pleased to be freed from her sleep. Her husband and her children were dissatisfied with this, and she herself obviously regretted that she had lost her means of making money more than she rejoiced that she was cured. I had, I must admit, promised her to restore her sleep if she wished it, but it returned of itself soon after her discharge, as was to be expected, since I was no longer present; and those more powerful factors, as well as the old-standing autosuggestion, soon gained the upper hand again.
I stated in my evidence that Mrs. F.'s somnambulic sleep was real, and not simulated, and on this she was acquitted. She bad not been accused of quackery; she might have been punished for this offense. This ease has been dealt with more minutely in the Annate of the Society of Experimental Psychology, and my evidence is added to the report.
 
Continue to: