These cases, in which the action of the original suggestion cannot be easily inhibited, recall certain forms of insanity, such as melancholia cum stupore. Bancroft has shown that the disturbances of movement in this and other insanities can be brought about by a primary psychic process, even by a delusion, but that when the cause has passed, the disturbance of movement may persist automatically.

1 I have published many experiments bearing on this point in a book of mine, Der Rapport in der Hypnose, Untersuchungen uber den lierischen Magnetismus. Publications of the Society for Psychological Research, Parts 3 and 4; Leipzig, 1892.

Vincent denies that there is any tendency for the suggestion to become fixed in hypnosis; he has always been able to remove the suggestion at once. Nevertheless, he remarks in a subsequent passage that he has sometimes found opposition during several seconds; but that is only to be regarded as an auto-suggestion; whether one refers it to auto-suggestion or not is a matter of indifference. The phenomenon is found in a certain group of cases.

I order a person to stretch out his right arm stiffly. The arm is stretched out, and the subject is unable to bend it of his own accord. In most cases, directly I command the arm to be bent it can be done; but there are some cases in which the experimenter is unable to put an end to the contracture at once, but the effect of the earlier idea continues.

A particular movement can also be continued for a long time in the same way. The so-called automatic movements described by Liebeault and Bernheim, or continued movements, as Max Dessoir more properly terms them, belong to the same category. If we turn the arms of an hypnotic round and round each other, the tendency to continue the movement persists, even after the experimenter has ceased to compel it by stopping turning his own arms. This also happens when the subject believes he has to go on turning. In some cases he continues turning his arms passively, while on other occasions he makes the strongest possible effort to keep them still, particularly when requested to do so. Such resistance is, however, useless; but in most cases a new suggestion of the experimenter that the arms shall stop is enough to arrest the movements at once. Sometimes, however, the experimenter finds it impossible to obtain an immediate arrest by a counter-command. I have often observed that a movement has continued for some time in spite of my order. We can also induce alternate movements of drawing up and stretching out in the arm and leg, and nodding and shaking of the head, etc. A particular movement can also be continued for a long time in the same way, when once started.

Again, I lift up an arm and bend it gently at the elbow-joint; directly I let go it repeats the movement. If it is desired that the hypnotic shall walk and he does not obey the command, let him be pulled forward a little; he will then when left to himself continue to walk (Heidenhain). The involuntary laughter, which I have often heard, is connected with this; it begins on command, or on a slight provocation. There are also pathological cases of uncontrollable laughter, showing decided resemblance to these cases. of hypnosis; Feodoroff, who has published several observations, refers it to a weakening of the will and, consequently, to a similar condition to that found in hypnosis. This laughter in hypnosis also resembles the cheerfulness produced by haschisch; under the influence of this drug, expressions which are quite insignificant excite involuntary laughter (Moleschott). Obersteiner has observed the hypnotic laugh in his own case, and has described it.

In some cases the passivity of the subject is so great that the suggestion of the experimenter is unable to overcome the muscular relaxation. Subjects of this kind let their arms drop after they have been raised, in spite of all suggestions. Questions are not answered, or only slight movements of the lips show that they have been heard at all. Two different types of hypnosis, which are called active and passive, may be distinguished by the absence or presence of this muscular relaxation. The passive form has a great external likeness to natural sleep, while the latter might be taken for a normal state on superficial observation. Passive hypnosis is not considered by some authors (Braid) as a form of hypnosis, but is considered to be a sleep, because the especial symptom is wanting which those investigators regard as the necessary characteristic of hypnosis - namely, catalepsy. This does not appear to me absolutely necessary in order to show hypnosis. Hypnosis often shows itself as passive at the beginning: as soon as the eyes are closed the head drops forward or backward, because the supporting muscles of the neck are relaxed.

There are many transitional states between active and passive hypnosis, and one often passes into the other.

The motor disturbances which appear in the eye must here be particularly discussed. We have already seen that many hypnoses are characterized only by the closing of the eyes - a fact already known to Heidenhain - while in many cases this is added to other symptoms. But closing of the eyes can also be influenced by suggestion, and an order of the experimenter is enough in most cases to cause their instantaneous opening. Closing of the eyes greatly favours the appearance of other hypnotic phenomena, but is not absolutely indispensable. There are persons who can be thrown into the deepest stage of hypnosis by a deep gaze, without the eyes closing at all (Gurney).

Although, as we have seen, closing of the eyes is not a necessary preface to hypnosis, yet the eyes are in most cases closed, and it is often impossible to permit them to open without ending the hypnosis at once. Even when the eyes open during the continuance of hypnosis, there is in many-cases a certain heaviness in the lids and a desire to close them. Much depends, however, upon the method employed; and primary fascination in particular always occurs while the eyes are wide open. The closing of the eyes is sometimes very gentle, and not spasmodic; though in a number of cases the muscles which close the eye contract spasmodically. Braid and Heidenhain already pointed out that when the lids close, even in the deepest hypnosis, the closing is not always complete. There is often a little chink of opening, and this is not unimportant, because many experiments in "clairvoyance," and also pretended "reading with the pit of the stomach," may be explained by the ability to see through this small opening.