This section is from the book "Hypnotism", by Dr. Albert Moll. Also available from Amazon: Hypnotism.
By placing a subject back in some earlier period of life - childhood, for example - Krafft-Ebing endeavoured to obtain an experimental solution of the question as to whether events which have disappeared from consciousness can be brought back during hypnosis. He considers that his experiments have settled this question in the affirmative, and further thinks that the changes in handwriting and style of expression noticed in such cases are typical of what the subject must have been when a child. But a different interpretation of Krafft-Ebing's experiments has been given by other investigators. Jolly, Kohler, and Loewenfeld assume that when such a subject behaves like a child he does not really depict his own childhood, but taking the experimenter's suggestion to mean that he should act like any child, he behaves as he imagines a child would. I think that this interpretation may be taken as generally accurate. Still, we must not exclude the possibility of that form of hypnotic hypermnesia being occasionally met with; a suitable subject could easily be influenced in that way, with the result that a mnemonic image would be reproduced.
New memories can be created at the time the old ones are cancelled. This is the case with the phenomenon which Charles Richet describes as objectivation des types. In this case the subject believes himself another personality, another being; not only do many memories connected with his own ego disappear, but he also endeavours to connect the remaining memories with his suggested personality. Durand de Gros was acquainted with these phenomena; he appears to have come across them in America, where they were already observed in 1840.
I told a. certain Mr. X. that he was Dr. Moll, and that I was Mr. X.; upon which he asked me to take a seat, so that he might hypnotize me. He attempted to do so; he went carefully through the process which I go through with him, and did not forget to make several pleasant suggestions.
I experimented with another man in whom these phenomena are very easily produced. He would represent with dramatic vividness any character which was within the grasp of his ideas. I told him, "You are Napoleon I.," upon which he immediately assumed the famous position of Napoleon after the battle of Waterloo, but spoke German, as he did not know French. As Frederick the Great, he walked with a crutch in the well-known gait, and knew nothing about railroads. Subjects can be made to believe they are animals; they will bark like dogs, or croak like frogs. They can even by suggestion be changed into inanimate objects, such as stoves, chairs, tables. When X. thinks himself a chair he crouches down on both legs; when it is suggested that the chair has a broken leg, he sinks his knee to the ground and rests on one leg; when he is a carpet he lies flat and motionless. These experiments in suggestion may be carried still further. "You are made of glass," I say to a hypnotic; he stands perfectly still.
When I tell another that he is made of marble, he stands stiffly and cannot be moved; but directly he believes himself to be made of wax he becomes plastic and allows himself to be placed in any attitude.
It should be remarked that the subject always obeys the experimenter, even when he believes himself an inanimate object. Moreover, hypnotized subjects are not always consistent in these experiments; they often forget their part, though this may be generally prevented by training. For example, another person whom I had changed into Frederick the Great travelled contentedly in a railway carriage, evidently not reflecting that there were no railways in those days. Another, whom I had carried back into the year 1864, spoke of the new German Empire, of the Emperor William I. In spite of such inconsistencies, the mental images are much more consistent with hypnotics than with many lunatics who believe themselves to be kings and prophets. The inconsistencies of lunatics are much greater, and hypnotics sooner get rid of them. Besides this, when they represent a new personality, memories of former experiences disappear more completely than is the case with lunatics' (Cullerre). In hypnotic change of personality each change is usually accompanied by loss of memory of that which preceded it.
One person whom I hypnotized was unable to remember as Napoleon what he had done as Frederick the Great.
The change of personality in hypnotics has often been compared with the performances of actors. It is the opinion of the actress Dumesnil that the actor who himself creates the idea of his part and allows himself to be governed by it will play his part the best; others - for example, the famous Clairon - held a different opinion on this point. In any case, few actors are able to accommodate and assimilate their own idea of a character - e.g., that of Julius Caesar, as thoroughly as a hypnotic can do. The subject is not distracted by sense-perceptions, while the actor cannot avoid being affected by them. Some actors, in order to play their parts as naturally as possible, call up imaginary objects by force of imagination, so as to place themselves amongst suitable surroundings.
Graphological investigations have been undertaken in several quarters in order to decide whether the handwriting of the hypnotized subject changes with the personality, and if the change bears any relation to the personality. Changes have been observed (Lombroso, Ferrari, Hericourt, Richet, Varinard, Mayeras). The expert Hoctes, however, thinks that the subject's handwriting is never altered to such a degree as not to be recognizable. I have never seen distinct changes of handwriting follow on change of personality; only in some cases when I placed the subjects in different periods of life has the handwriting altered. As children they wrote awkwardly and made mistakes in spelling; as old people they wrote shakily. The trials made with Krafft-Ebing's patient, who wrote different hands, corresponding to the different earlier periods of her life, are very interesting; unfortunately, the writing could not be compared with true writing of the subject at those periods. Sidis has published similar experiments. In one case, however, Krafft-Ebing was able to compare the handwriting of a hypnotic placed in an earlier period of life with the subject's actual handwriting at that period, and thinks he could trace a certain similarity between the two.
 
Continue to: