To persist in calling this a case of suggestion because the hypnosis was produced by suggestion, would be to attribute to the word suggestion a meaning far beyond permissible limits. In what we call suggestion there must be at least a direct connection between the effect produced, and the idea of that effect. When this connection is wanting we are not justified in ascribing other mental connections - association, for example - to hypnosis, quite apart from the fact that there may possibly be processes of a purely physiological nature which lead to a decrease of sense-perception without the intervention of any mental activity being demonstrable. At all events, I consider that no proof has yet been adduced to show that all the diminutions of sense-perception met with in hypnosis are due to suggestion, as defined by me on page 66.

No matter what opinion we may hold on the origin of those diminutions of sense-perception which we have described up to this point, there can be no doubt that many changes of sense-perception can be brought about by suggestion in hypnosis. Analgesia, for example, often exists to such a degree that the severest surgical operations can be performed during the state. It is also known that needles may be run into some persons during hypnosis, without their feeling the pain, though they feel the touch. And yet a complete analgesia is rare in hypnosis. There is an immense difference between pricking a person with a needle and using the faradic brush. The pain caused' by the use of the latter is so great, especially when the current is sufficiently strong, that very few persons in hypnosis can endure it, even when they show no pain on being pricked with a needle. At all events, decreased sensitiveness to pain can often be induced by suggestion, although an absolute, complete analgesia is rarely attained by that means. Many cases described as completely analgesic - for example, those of Tamburini and SeppiHi - proved on closer examination not to be so, as a strong faradic current finally produced pain.

I will just remark that all kinds of pain can be induced by suggestion - the pain caused by a needle, as well as that caused by a knife or burn. The face of the subject expresses pain in such a manner, that an impartial person can hardly decide whether the pain is real or suggested.

Tactual sensibility, the sense of temperature, etc., can also be anaesthetized by suggestion as well as the sense of pain. The mucous membranes, too, can be rendered insensible. The fumes of ammonia in the nose, and tickling the throat, are not felt; the conjunctiva can be touched without producing the corresponding reflex; even the cornea may become insensitive, either spontaneously or by suggestion (Bramwell). Preyer quotes the cynical experiment of an American physician, Little, who thrust a needle through the cornea of a hypnotic whom he suspected of simulation, in order to test its insensibility. But in my experience these last-mentioned phenomena are uncommon. When this anaesthesia of the conjunctiva and cornea exists the eye no longer closes on reflex stimulus; but this is a consequence of the anaesthesia, and not an independent phenomenon (Gurney).

Attention must be drawn to another phenomenon, which, however, cannot be straightway ascribed to suggestion. Dollken, like Bechterew, Lannegrace and others, has observed that when there is a general decrease in the sensibility of the skin, the function of the eye and ear are also impaired. But he never found the opposite to be the case. Dollken, as well as Schaffer, further found that when one side of the body was made anaesthetic by suggestion all the organs of sense were affected; there were also motor disturbances. For example, in such cases of hemianaesthesia by suggestion he observed the following changes on the anaesthetized side: - Cessation of the functions of the senses of pain, touch, and temperature; incapacity for carrying out delicate movements with the hand, extending in some cases to loss of movement of the upper extremity, also locomotor disturbances and loss of the power to walk. The muscular force was nil, the field of vision apparently concentrically narrowed, the hearing less acute, the sense of smell and the muscular sense appreciably diminished; finally there was decrease, and in one case cessation, of the patellar reflex, even when the muscles were completely relaxed.

Further, amaurosis induced by suggestion was invariably accompanied by a decrease of the functions of the senses of smell and hearing - a fact already established by Schaffer. Amblyopia, hyposmia, and slight hypaesthesia were observed in cases of deafness brought about by suggestion. Since Dollken excluded the action of suggestion in the production of these secondary symptoms, they are very remarkable as sequelae of primary suggestion. If we compare these secondary symptoms with the loss of sensation which directly follows the loss of motor power in paralysis. by suggestion (p. 72), the similarity of the two phenomena strikes one at once. In such cases as those with which we have just been dealing, it is quite possible that processes may be at work which we are not justified in ascribing to suggestion, even if there naturally remain a suspicion that the secondary symptoms may have been induced by ideas unintentionally suggested.

I have shown above that perceptions of each sense by itself can be prevented by suggestion; but hyperesthesias of the organs of sense likewise exist in hypnosis. Whether these come on from suggestion, or in other ways, is, as mentioned above, not always to be distinguished exactly. Although they are not on the whole very common, I shall here add some of these very remarkable cases. It is exactly these rarer cases which deserve the most careful consideration, for they often offer us a key to a natural explanation of many mysterious phenomena, such as transposition of the senses, and clairvoyance.