Of all the phenomena connected with hypnotism that of "suggestion" is so striking and so evident that to the lay mind it overshadows all else. It seems to be so far removed from anything in the ordinary state that it wears the air of the supernatural. All the more so, since charlatans, and even enthusiastic honest operators, through unconscious imposition, often have pushed this phase until the capacity of the credulous has been taxed to the utmost limit, and conservative persons have turned from the whole subject in disgust, condemning even that which is true and really exists. A closer analysis will show, however, that we have in hypnotism and suggestion, merely states and effects which have their parallel in the ordinary sleeping, nay, even in the waking state. In man the hypnotic state is made up of two elements, - one resembling the condition more or less closely which we call "sleep," and like it, induced by monotonous impressions coupled with fatigue; the other, - the state of "suggestibility," the capacity to receive the so-called suggestions, in which the will and the phantasy of the subject are under the control and direction of the operator.

This direction may be exercised by-spoken-words, as is usually done, by showing of objects, by placing the limbs in a certain position, or by any sign or means of communication. For a comprehension, then, of suggestion, it will be necessary to review the mental and physical states in ordinary sleep. In ordinary sleep, we have a condition which comes on periodically, and in which the higher functions of the brain are for the time abolished or much reduced in activity, the lower ones, however, as those which control breathing and the beating of the heart are still active. Impressions made on the sense organs attain to no influence on the soul life; they produce no perceptions, much less a train of co-ordinated thought. A sound, a spoken word, for instance, reaches the ear; it sets the auditory apparatus in motion, the impression is carried into the brain, but yet, it does not come to our perception or give a lucid concept because the higher parts of the brain where these processes go on, are for the time incapable of work, - are asleep. There are various stages or degrees of sleep.

Once it is so deep that the greatest disturbances are passed over, then again so light that the slightest impression will drive it away, - sometimes absolutely dreamless, at other times sleep is filled with dreams of which - and this is a point to be noted - we may have indistinct and confused recollection only, or it may be that every detail can be vividly recalled, just as in the hypnotic state we may have complete oblivion of what has passed during that period, or the subject may remember all that has transpired. Rarely are our dreams logical or rational in all of their details; usually some of their occurrences are more or less senseless. We jump a thousand feet, traverse miles of country in an instant, or do similar impossible feats without surprise. This shows that only some of the brain functions, as fancy and recollection, are concerned, are awake, whereas the ordering, reasoning faculties are in abeyance, are asleep. Through external irritation of the nerves, dreams may be artificially produced with, generally, a gross misconception of the cause actually existing.

The sound of running water has produced dreams of rains and summer showers; a rapping on the door has called up pictures of cannonading; just as in the hypnotic state it is possible to see a bird instead of the handkerchief actually in view or taste an apple for the raw potato which is being chewed. Muscular movements may be executed during sleep. Eiders and drivers often sleep during their time of duty without dropping their reins or falling off their seats. Movements may be made as the result of external impressions. If, during sleep, the foot becomes uncovered and chilled it will be drawn back. Tickling may cause movements indicating dissatisfaction or even attempts to push the offending object away, all without awakening the person. So, too, a command may be followed, as when a child is told to turn over in bed or extend an arm. Here, again, is a train of occurrences found in the hypnotic state. Another fact connected with sleep throws further light on this subject, which is, that under certain circumstances a certain definite cause or stimulus alone will be effective, others not.

A mother will fall asleep at her baby's side unhampered by surrounding noises, but at the first sound of the child's cry she will wake; the physician will sleep soundly, maybe, in the heart of the city with all its noise and din, but the sound of his door or telephone bell, less intense than surrounding noises, will awaken him instantly, because as in the case above, sleep has come with the idea fixed in the mind that a certain sound and no other should cause awakening; so the hypnotized subject will wake at the command given for that purpose and not by other sounds or signals. As already stated we find, even in the waking state, conditions like and explanatory of those found in the hypnotic. Every idea or conception formed in man produces in him a certain effect which may be internal only, or may find expression in external manifestations. If one forms a mental concept of the deluge, a picture of Noah and his ark will involuntarily arise in the mind. If one formulates the idea of fear or of pleasure, this will often produce a corresponding change in the facial expression and sometimes even movements of various muscles of the body.

The effect produced by a mental concept will depend largely upon the peculiarities of the person, his educational status, character, habits, and mental condition at the time. So some persons make "good" hypnotic subjects; will respond freely and fully to suggestion. Others are "poor" in that the responses are slight and less profuse. All persons are at times susceptible to "suggestion," to being influenced by word or act of others to a greater or lesser degree. In many instances a person, A, may, by persuasive talk or action, produce a certain intended effect on B, just as the operator does with his subject in hypnotic sleep. Even actions not under the control of the will may thus be brought about frequently. It is sufficient to say to a person slightly embarrassed, "Why are you blushing?" to have the reddening of the face actually take place. The term "rapport" expresses the, at first sight, wonderful fact that the subject will readily obey the commands or "suggestions" of the operator, but not so readily those of another person. This is readily explained by what has already been said and by further remembering that no one can be hypnotized against his own will.

He must be in full accord with the operator and goes to sleep with the idea fixed in his mind that the operator alone has his attention. This is essential for the success of "suggestion." Any preconceived resistance to the operator's will before hypnosis, will nullify as it would in the normal state, just as a willingness to comply will be followed by such results in either condition.

Post-hypnotic suggestion has been much discussed as a demonstration of the marvels of hypnotism. Here a suggestion is made to the hypnotic, which is to be carried out at some future time, days, weeks, or months ahead. Dr. Moll says he told a subject, "When you come here eight days hence you will be dumb," and actually on entering a week later, the individual lost his power of speech until the suggestion was removed.

Lawyers taking advantage of similar statements have in one or two criminal cases set up (though unsuccessfully) the plea that their clients committed the act as a post-hypnotic suggestion and were therefore not the real culprits.