This section is from the book "Hypnotism And Hypnotic Suggestion", by E. Virgil Neal, Charles S. Clark. Also available from Amazon: Hypnotism And Hypnotic Suggestion.
In all the earlier tests the subject knew in each case what kinds of images he was expected to select from the train following the exposure. After a time it was found easy to pass from letters to numerals as the case required. The final tests were given without this cue, the marginal characters being letters, numerals and blanks in irregular order.
We give here a table of the first twenty cases in the final test of R. It is not necessary to give other results for either 0 or R, as they are all similar. The striking difference between C and R was that 0 gave letters best and R numerals. In the course of the tesfs both subjects discovered by accident the presence of the actual characters in the margins and thus learned the purpose and conditions of the experiment. Yet the rate of improvement was not apparently modified by this knowledge and actual test showed them unable to see consciously the characters on the card when, the shutter was thrown under the same conditions as before. We thus have reasonable proof that the retina in the indirect field of these eyes carried in impressions not consciously seen and handed them over to the conscious self - impressions too weak to be directly experienced in vision.
The manner in which these impressions were received is worth noting. "When R wished to give the numeral or letter, he closed his eyes and usually began by saying, "I see," etc. Once, when 55 was the numeral, he replied to the usual interrogation by saying, with considerable hesitation, "I see a 5 with something before it I can. not make it out. I am certain the number is of two figures*" At another time the numeral was three - "I see an 8. No 1 it has changed to a 3." Any numeral ending in 6 gave him much trouble, as 46 was often read 40, 72, 12, etc. Sometimes he would say, "I see a figure but can not make it out. It seems to be Several in one." When the margin was blank he usually saw nothing at first and was very reluctant to answer, saying that the figures were slow to come and very dim. C did not dose his eyes and gave his answers very promptly, but said the images rose up in his mind as in case of R.
It will be observed that many of the errors in the table may be explained as misreadings by the eye, or such as would be made in determining the content of vague memory eye images.
Another series of experiments was made upon eight college students,' one of them giving results similar to the early tests of C and R. Thus we have found three susceptible cases in fourteen. So far no attempt has been made to train the less promising subjects.
Strangely enough, if in these experiments, the eye was fixed upon the point where the picture was to appear and the attention given to the indirect field of vision, the letters and numerals on the end of the card were not only invisible but could not be given correctly as in the case of attention directed elsewhere. That is to say the necessary conditions of attention are here the same as in cases of automatic writing or in double personality.
The finale to this series of experiments would be the training of the hand of the subject to record the marginal letters independently. This is still more difficult and tedious. It has been tried with a new subject and, though the results are encouraging, no certain statement can be made at this time. However, these meagre results lend more weight to the idea that we are here dealing with the same relations of consciousness that appear in an exaggerated form as a secondary personality.
Now, let us see what light these results throw upon hypnotism. One of the most striking facts of hypnotism is that commands given the hypnotic personality are afterwards executed at the appointed time by the normal personality. The individual denies all knowledge of being so commanded, maintaining that the idea of the act was original with him and that it was done because of no good reason for not doing it. Here an idea comes into consciousness without a trace of relation in time and space to other conscious acts. In the case of R, images of numerals rose up in consciousness and differed from the images of the pictures on the card, in that he was conscious of seeing the latter at a given place and at a certain time in relation to his other conscious acts, while in case of numerals, he was only conscious of an image rising up in mind whose counterpart had no place in his experience and for whose presence he can give no explanation save that it just came. In such manner fragmentary memories may be taken from the mental series of the hypnotic personality and transferred to the normal mental series, free from all old connections so that the subject is tricked into accepting it as a new and original experience.
It is possible that such a method may account for many of the ideas that come to normal people, as it were, out of the air, but we believe this occurs far less often than many writers would lead us to believe. The whole matter of the transfer of ideas from a subconscious personality to the conscious, or normal, is probably, at bottom, the same process by which we go through the common experience of feeling that the clock struck a certain hour while we were reading but do not know that we heard it strike nor can we even guess what we were doing while it did so. The real problem here, however, is to discover the mechanism by which this is brought about. This is so far a mystery.
Another cause for popular wonder is the acuteness of the senses sometimes observed in the hypnotic state. In the cases before mentioned, we see how the secondary personality receives impressions from stimuli below the threshold of the normal. From these it is not so surprising that in hypnotism, where the secondary personality is stimulated to great activity, the eye should become extremely acute or the ear exceedingly sharp.
The inducing of hypnotism by the operator and the training of our subjects to bring about exceptional phenomena of consciousness, all indicate that in such anomalies of personality we have an unusual relation of normal tendencies brought about by unusual circumstances. But an operator is not essential to these circumstances.
As we have already pointed out the one essential condition for the induction of automatic action of any kind is to get the attention firmly fixed on something else. It is generally agreed that in hypnotism we have a case of extreme concentration of attention somewhere to such a degree that the whole normal consciousness is held at a standstill, producing a condition not unlike natural sleep. So every one who can concentrate his attention has within him the fundamental possibilities of the various phenomena of the secondary personality.
From the experiments reported in this article, it seems possible to devise a series of tests for susceptibility of this kind by which individuals may be classified for study and practical considerations. This would enable us to make a more searching investigation of the relations between hypnotism and other characteristics and contribute greatly to our insight into human nature. The few experiments of the writer give no idea as to what percentage of people at large, or even of college students, exhibit these automatisms, hut they are probably more numerous than is generally believed. In the regular psycho-physical tests of students in Columbia College, all are asked if they have ever experienced a hallucination, an apparition, heard voices, etc., and the written replies contain many accounts of such experiences. Most of these heard voices calling them or making suggestions, other kinds being rare. Among 300 male students there were slightly more than 50 cases of such auditory experiences, ranging from single to constant occurrence and in varying degrees of complexity.
Many published reports of hypnotism show that the hypnotic personality is in possession of the memory store of the secondary personality present in automatic writing and alternating consciousness, and there are other facts indicating a similar relation between the latter and simple auditory illusions. On the other hand, these illusions seem to play a prominent part in certain classes of insanity. In view of this, considerations of mental health make it desirable to find means for detecting tendencies of this sort, and it is not unreasonable to hope that the future will give us a working knowledge in this important field.
Characters on the card. | Characters given by the subject. | |
13 . | ....13 or 15 | |
13 . | .......13 | |
37 . | .......17 | |
27 . | .......27 | |
46 . | .......7 | |
Z .. | ..........Z or X | |
( ) | ........(nothing) | |
55 . | ....25 or 35 | |
( ) | .......(nothing) | |
( ) | .......(nothing) | |
( ) | 7 (very doubtful) | |
2 . | .......6 | |
( ) | .......1 | |
Y . | .......7 | |
P.. | .......P | |
( ) | ........(nothing) | |
P . | ........R | |
( ) | .........(nothing) | |
75 . | .......15 | |
H . | .......H | |
 
Continue to: