One often hears the word "hypnosis" used as though the thing for which it stands were as definite an entity as typhoid fever or diphtheria. Any recognized disease consists of certain well-marked symptoms which succeed one another in a fairly constant order, and, taken together, they constitute a relatively permanent system. This is not true of "hypnosis." What in a disease would be called the "symptoms" are, it is true, fairly determinate in it so far as their character goes, but they occur in such irregular, seemingly haphazard, combination, that it is impossible to frame any definition of "hypnosis" which will not seem hopelessly arbitrary.

This tendency to make simple that which is really complex has resulted in much popular misapprehension, and in many superficial theories. The popular misapprehension is, perhaps, a minor matter, - it was inevitable at any rate, - but the superficial theories are, in part, preventable and are of more importance, for they have often delayed the progress of investigation by giving the false impression that the ends of science had been reached and that further study of the facts was thereby rendered unnecessary.

I wish to enumerate the more salient phenomena of the states termed "hypnotic," to point out their nearest analogues, to bring them under a common formula, and thus to show some of the questions which must be answered before a theory of their nature can be framed. But I do not intend to frame such a theory myself. The agencies used in the production of hypnotic states form a convenient starting point. They are two in number, - fixation of attention and the suggestion, "Go to sleep." The fixation of attention is usually prolonged, and various devices, such as passes and other monotonous sense rhythms, are used to prevent its wandering. But occasionally a sudden or violent arrest of attention, as for instance, that occasioned by a loud noise or by a brilliant flash of light, proves sufficient to induce an hypnotic state. The suggestion, "Go to sleep" is often expanded into a series of suggestions, all of which are really implied in it, as, "You are growing drowsy, your eyelids grow heavy, your hands numb/' etc., etc. The relative importance of these two factors has been much disputed. I believe that the fixation of attention is always essential. Even when one hypnotizes by suggestion alone, attention is fixed upon the hypnotizer and his suggestions.

But fixation of attention is not always, or even usually, sufficient to produce an hypnotic state for the first time, without suggestion. After the subject has been frequently hypnotized, however, he can be again thrown into an hypnotic state by anything to which the idea of being hypnotized has been attached, - he can even hypnotize himself.

The effects produced by such manipulations can be classed under six chief heads:

1. Disturbances of Motion.

2. Disturbances of Sensation.

3. Disturbances of Ideation.

4. Suggestibility.

5. Post-hypnotic and Sub-conscious States.

6. Rapport.

The most common disturbance of motion is paralysis. It usually begins in the eyelids, progressing thence to lips and tongue, fingers, hand, arm, body. But its progress is sometimes more irregular and it often does not go so far.

The disturbances in sensation may be in the direction of an increase or of a diminution in sensitiveness. Increase I have never seen, though it has been reported by others. Diminution may be partial, or may progress to total anaesthesia. Sensitiveness to pain is usually the first to be affected, then the others, but in case of the others I have never observed any order in their going. But one should remember that the deafness, for example, of an hypnotic state is very different from the deafness which is due to a destruction of the hearing machinery. It is more like the deafness of the boiler maker, who, though his hearing is perfectly good, will say that he 'does not hear/ the incessant hammering in the midst of which his waking hours are spent. To this I shall recur later.

The ideational effects are the most difficult to ascertain and to classify. There is no doubt that most commonly the flow of thought is stayed. The teeming trains of ideas become thinned out and the ideas that remain succeed one another much more slowly than in the normal state. Thinking becomes an effort and soon comes to an apparent stop. But sometimes precisely the opposite is observed. Sober thought is replaced by vivid dreams, very like those of normal sleep, or by a swift stream of relatively coherent ideas poured forth in a "sermon" or "lecture." Between these extremes, again, lie all manner of intermediate states. Memory also is generally profoundly influenced and often for the better. The subject can often recall with precision many trifling happenings which he has entirely forgotten in his waking life. But occasionally memory seems to be split into mutually exclusive strata, the subject remembering the occurrences of previous hypnotic states only, or of certain periods of his life only.

When this happens, one has reason to suspect that the subject's waking memory is not normal,- but this question is too broad for discussion here.

As a rule, the occurrences of the hypnotic state are not recalled after awaking. But the rule has many exceptions and I think that altogether too much emphasis has been laid upon it by many writers. The most characteristic change which hypnotizing works in the inner life is also the most difficult to define. We are all familiar with a something which we term the "self" and with the acts of will and of effort which we ascribe to the "self" in a peculiarly intimate sense; but it is not easy to define what we mean by the "self," or by ascribing to it acts of will and of effort. Whatever it be, this it is which is most affected in hypnotic states. It seems to lose, in a large measure, its power of initiation and of resistance. Whenever the subject can remember enough of the hypnotic state to describe his feelings this is the one thing upon which he lays most emphasis. He will say he felt "drowsy" or "lazy" or "helpless;" that he often recognized the commands of the hypnotizer as absurd, but was either unable or disinclined to resist their execution.