This section is from the book "Hypnotism: How It Is Done; Its Uses And Dangers", by James R. Cocke. Also available from Amazon: Hypnotism: How It Is Done; Its Uses And Dangers.
In the early part of this book I took exception to the term "hypnotism" as denoting sleep. I said that many of the hypnotized subjects were not asleep, but, on the contrary, were very actively awake. Having myself been hypnotized a number of times, I shall describe for the sake of comparison the sensatious which occurred to me during the passage into the hypnotic state, and while it lasted. I do not claim that the sensations which I experienced were those which are always experienced. In fact, for reasons which I shall give later, I think they differ in some degree from those which are commonly felt.
I have questioned a large number of persons who were hypnotized by myself and by others, and have found that the sensations are essentially different according to the narrator. Every physician who has tried to analyze the symptoms of a patient knows how difficult it often is to get from him a perfectly clear and comprehensive statement of his exact sensations.
I have questioned some fifty persons who were anaesthetized by chloroform, ether, laughing-gas, etc. Also I have questioned a number of persons who had been intoxicated. In none of these latter were the symptoms identical. Neither were descriptions of those upon whom anaesthetics were used identical. Some would say that chloroform simply made them feel as though they were going to sleep. Others would speak of suffocating sensations. Others would have dreams, some pleasant, some unpleasant, and so I might go on for pages with their descriptions. Hence it follows that if the sensations differ in different persons with the same agent employed to produce these sensations, whether it be drugs or hypnotism, no uniform description of sensations could be made to apply to all. My own sensations during the first hypnosis I ever experienced were as follows.
I voluntarily submitted in the spring of 1882 to a professional hypnotist. He commanded me to close my eyes, and said that I could not open them. I tried to open them at once and did so. Again he commanded me to close my eyes. He stroked my head and face and eyelids with his fingers.
Now, it is to be noted that at that time I was a firm believer in the doctrine of animal magnetism. I felt, or imagined that I felt, a tingling sensation in my forehead and in my eyes, which I supposed emanated from the fingers of the operator. A sensation akin to fear came over me. The operator said to me, "You are going to sleep, you are getting sleepy. You cannot open your eyes." I was conscious that my heart was beating rapidly and felt a sensation of terror. He continued to tell me that I was going to sleep, and could not open my eyes. He then made passes over my head, down over my hands and body, but did not touch me. He then said to me, "You cannot open your eyes." The motor apparatus of my lids would not seemingly respond to my will, yet I was conscious that while one part of my mind wanted to open my eyes, another part did not want to, so I was in a paradoxical state. I believed, that I could open my eyes and yet could not. The feeling of not wishing to open them was not based upon any desire to please the operator. I had no personal interest in him in any way, but, be it understood, I firmly believed in his power to control me.
He continued to suggest to me that I was going to sleep, and the sensation of terror previously mentioned continued to increase.
He told me that I was asleep, and placed my hand over my head, and stated that it was rigid, and that I could not put it down. Again a part of my consciousness wanted to put it down, and another part did not. He stroked my arm and told me that it was growing numb, that it was growing insensible. He told me that I had no feeling in it. He said, "You have no feeling in it, have you!" I said, "No," and I knew that I said "No," yet I knew that I had feeling in it, and yet believed that I had no feeling in it. He pricked my hand with a pin, and said, "You do not experience any sensation." Again I answered in the negative. He said, "You feel no fatigue in the arm," and continued to prick me at intervals with a pin. He made many suggestions to me and I obeyed them, The sensation of terror continued to increase. I was not conscious of my body at all, but was painfully conscious of the two contradictory elements within me. I knew that my body existed, but could not prove it to myself. I knew that the statements made by the operator were in a measure untrue. I obeyed them voluntarily and involuntarily. This is the last remembrance that I have of that hypnotic experience. The operator commanded me to drop my arm. I knew when I did it.
It seemed to me that he commanded me to wake immediately afterwards. Persons around me, upon whom I could rely, told me a number of things which I did after dropping my arm at the command of the hypnotist, but I had no memory of them. Now, if I acted in an unconscious condition, it is perfectly clear that I could have no memory of what did not exist for the time, viz., my consciousness. It is well known to the medical profession that in that condition known as puerperal eclampsia (convulsions occurring at childbirth), the sufferer will be totally ignorant of the time elapsing during the period of the convulsions. The memory of days and even weeks will be wholly effaced. Now, if I was unconscious during the hypnotic state mentioned, it follows that my sense of the time which elapsed was also in abeyance, for it seemed to me that the hypnotist commanded me to awake as soon as I dropped my arm, although I was assured by those around me, who were my friends, that I was in this state some ten minutes after the last command of which I was conscious was given. On coming out of the hypnotic condition I was somewhat dizzy. The sensation of terror clung to me for eight or ten hours afterwards.
I was hypnotized three times subsequently by the same man with similar results, the sensations being practically the same each time. 1 discovered for myself on the evening following the third hypnotic sitting that I could place myself by an act of my own will in a similar condition. I did not at that time know that auto-hypnosis was possible as I had never heard of it. Owing to an imperfection of sight, the hypnotist could not hypnotize me by having me look at a bright coin (after the Braid method), because I could not see it. He told me to fix my mind on the number twenty-six and hold up my hand. This I did, and passed into a state of deep hypnosis, experiencing in a greater degree the sensation of terror before mentioned. This was in his presence and at the third hypnotic treatment which I had with him, and was in the morning at ten o'clock.
In my room that evening it occurred to me; to try the same experiment. I did so. I kept the number twenty-six in my mind, in a few minutes I felt the sensation of terror but in a different way. I was intensely cold. My heart seemed to stand still. I had tinnitus aurium (ringing in the ears). My hair seemed to rise upon my scalp. I persisted in the effort, and the previously mentioned noise in my ears grew louder and louder. The roar became deafening. It crackled like a mighty fire. I was fearfully conscious of myself. Having read vivid accounts of dreams, visions, etc., it occurred to me that I would experience them. I felt in a vague way that there were beings all about me but could not hear their voices. I felt as though every muscle in my body was fixed and rigid.
The roaring in my ears grew louder still, and I heard, above the roar, reports which sounded like artillery and musketry. Then, above the din of the noise, a musical chord. I seemed to be absorbed in this chord. I knew nothing else. The world existed for me only in the tones of this mighty chord. Then I had a sensation as though I were expanding. The sound in my ears died away, and yet I was not conscious of silence. Then all consciousness was lost. The next thing I experienced was a sensation of intense cold, and of some one roughly shaking me. Then I heard the voice of my jolly landlord calling me by name, and asking if I were ill. I awoke with the taste of brandy in my mouth. My landlord had come into the room to read the newspaper to me, as was his custom, and found me stretched out in a reclining-chair. As ho expressed it, "I was as white as a ghost and as limp as a rag," and he thought I was dead. He says it took him ten minutes to arouse me, which was probably true, as his good wife in the meantime brought a physician who lived near, who naturally had his visit in vain.
I did not explain the cause of my indisposition.
As will he seen from the description which I have given, a sensation of terror was the predominating feeling when I was hypnotized, both by the operator and when the state was induced by myself upon myself.
The sensations experienced by me did not resemble sleep. They did not resemble chloroform or ether narcosis, as these have been used on me several times, and the memory of them is fresh in my mind.
The sensations in the hypnotic state did not resemble the sensations produced by morphine or chloral, as I have used both of these drugs, and remember well how they affected me. Whatever may be the experiences of others, I am convinced that the result was brought about in my own case by the following agencies.
I firmly believed that something would happen when the attempt was made to hypnotize me. Secondly, I wished to be hypnotized. These, together with a vivid imagination and strained attention, brought on the states which occurred.
How far I could have carried this and what the result would have been, I cannot say; but one thing I am sure of, and I speak now for myself only, I could not have been hypnotized against my will. Neither do I believe that any one else could be unless terror or strong faith for the time paralyzed the volition.
I do not believe the hypnotist had any power over me excepting the power which my surrender to ray own faith and my own imagination, plus the attention and terror, gave him.
These experiments were repeated thrice during the following week, and in the third one the phenomena differed somewhat. I had several dreams in addition to the sense of terror present in the other two. I heard voices, some of them profane, some ludicrous, and all of them in a measure coherent. I awoke easily this time, having remained in the state about two hours.
I consulted the hypnotist who first hypnotized me, but, as he was an ignorant man, got little satisfaction from him. He was a public hyp-notizer - that is, he gave exhibitions of hypnotism for the entertainment of the public. He advised mo to discontinue my experiments upon myself, as he was afraid I would do myself harm (this was good advice), and stated that I would better not submit to hypnotism, except when he hypnotized me (which was doubtful advice).
I have compared the sensations experienced by me with those of many others who have been hypnotized. In some respects the experiences of those who were consulted resembled my own, but not in every particular.
Close analysis of the language of those with whom I have conversed about the sensations which they experienced while being hypnotized, has convinced me that none of the states occurring in hypnosis are identical with those of natural sleep.
I have not determined whether the hallucinations of suggestion affect the consciousness in the same way as do dreams occurring in natural sleep.
 
Continue to: