This section is from the book "Biology In Human Affairs", by Walter Van Dyke Bingham. Also available from Amazon: Biology In Human Affairs.
But man's natural defenselessness has affected his social evolution in another profound manner. It was an essential condition of his gregarious habit. There is obviously some question whether man has a truly gregarious instinct. Moreover, the easy explanation of human behavior as due to this or that instinct is distinctly less popular to-day than it was even a decade or two ago. Still further, it is not quite certain that man began the group habit of living in consequence of an instinctive tendency rather than as a result of an intellectual perception of its utility. It seems probable that in many habitats the individual family, or even the solitary person, could have managed to exist without the advantages of group cooperation (especially after the acquisition of crude weapons, if we may suppose such to have been possible in the absence of associated life); but that would have been a precarious and ill-adapted mode of life. Not only from the standpoint of food getting, but also from that of reproduction, life in a horde would have been superior to seclusion. I think we are warranted in holding at least that man acquired an instinctive predisposition toward the acquisition of gregarious habits.
Such gregariousness as man developed, however, was not that of the bovine herd. Religion has long and often urged man to submission and humility, but has seemed to succeed only with the weaker members of the species. In order to understand human history as an expression of human nature, one must see man as an extremely complex and highly variable creature basically much more akin to the Canidae than to the Bovidae. It is no mere unique and accidental phenomenon that the dog was the first domesticated animal and that there is a more sympathetic and intimate understanding between man and dog than between man and any other animal. The thesis advanced and admirably sustained by Professor Carveth Read1 that man is descended from a wolf-ape which acquired a taste for meat and developed the habit of hunting in packs is at least plausible. Such a theory, in any case, is in harmony with those conditions of life essential to the development of longer legs, agility, erect stature, intelligence, language, and social life. Moreover, it is in harmony, not only with the universality of the hunting-pack pattern in social life, but also with characteristic psychological traits expressing themselves therein. Conspicuous among these traits are those of leadership and following, an order of precedence, rivalry, loyalty, lust of the chase and the thrill of killing, cunning and strategy. The leader must prove his superiority and must be followed with unswerving loyalty. The individual must cooperate with the pack and hence must be subservient to the interests and moods of his group. Nothing is more common at all stages of human evolution than the formation by strong and aggressive men of bands of followers for purposes of hunting, fighting, robbing, plundering, intimidating, and otherwise controlling and regulating the lives of weaker or less well-organized persons. Among our Nordic ancestors, to live by robbery and plunder was honorable and meritorious, and the comitatus, or organization of chief, lieutenants, and followers, was the unit out of which have been forged 1 Read, Carveth,"The Origin of Man,"Cambridge University Press (The Macmillan Company, New York), 1925.
feudatories innumerable. Those patterns of social organization, made so familiar and so conspicuous by the well-developed feudal order, are exemplified in the Australian tribe, in the Indian hunting or war party, and in many phases of modern life, such as governmental institutions and political parties, business corporations and racket gangs, ecclesiastical institutions and university faculties.
As stated above, man is more wolfish than bovine in temperament. The instinctive tendencies of the herd animal are manifested by huddling together, running in the same direction, heightened suggestibility in times of danger, uneasiness in isolation, and obvious pleasure on being restored to the herd. Man manifests these traits to a considerable degree. He loses himself in the crowd which he readily follows and whose mental attitudes he thoughtlessly shares; his high suggestibility is repeatedly manifested in his collective gullibility, especially in times of group danger; he finds solitary confinement a dreadful punishment and rejoices in the restoration of free association with his fellows. On the other hand, the herd animal is non-aggressive, prone to flee from danger, and manifests aggressiveness only under severe provocation; it does not find in the chase, warfare, and killing either a continuous interest or deep emotional gratification; it knows nothing of strategy, courage, or indomitable will in attack; it feeds quietly, slowly, and peacefully and not greedily, enviously, and pugnaciously. Man shares with the dog and wolf those traits in which they differ from the bovine herd animals. These traits are by no means an adequate representation of his highly complex nature, but it is easier to understand him and his history in the light of such a biological interpretation than in that of the softer view assiduously cultivated by authoritarian myth and given credence by human vanity. He is, in fact, the fighting animal par excellence, but he fights with greater gusto in a group than when alone. Like other creatures he will fight when alone to preserve his life and, in some cases, his honor and dignity; but in groups his courage and confidence are enormously elevated, his sense of power and adequacy become inflated, and he becomes aggressive, domineering, and blood-thirsty. In view of his historical record, the devoutly cultivated myth that man was created in the image of a loving God and endowed with a sweet, kindly nature only a little lower than that of the angels, must be looked upon as a most extraordinary compensatory rationalization. Every page of human history is spotted with senseless and unnecessary bloodshed, crimes of violence and ferocious brutality. Warfare and crimes of robbery and violence, individual and collective, seem to be ineradicable from human relations, just as are also the existence of Tammany Halls and Ohio gangs in politics, and exploitation and monopoly in business.
 
Continue to: