This section is from the book "Massage And Medical Gymnastics", by Emil A. G. Kleen. Also available from Amazon: Massage and medical gymnastics.
The opponents of the fixation treatment, on the other hand, feared the muscular atrophy which was bound to follow such long-continued fixation, and they considered that in practice they had found that such fixation is most often injurious - that it more often aggravates than improves a case of scoliosis.
Now after two or three decades we can begin to criticise the situation, and strenuous work in many well-equipped orthopaedic institutions of various countries has done much to elucidate this difficult question. One sees at once that the great hopes entertained, more especially by those orthopaedists most interested in biology, have by no means been fulfilled. This, of course, does not mean that the biological theories which lay at the root of the fixation treatment were wrong, but depends on other conditions. It is partly due to the fact that the chest, which is the chief point of fixation tor all apparatus aiming at fixation of the spine in a certain position, cannot, with its movable and changeable contents, be fixed in the same sense as part of a leg or arm can be fixed by a plaster bandage. It is also partly due to the same fault having been made in the application of the theory to the treatment of scoliosis that was made in reference to the treatment of several other deformities by static means according to Wolff's law. It was forgotten that the form of any part of the skeleton is not due merely to physical forces, but that its function is always many-sided - e.g., in reference to the spine it is not only to carry weight. It was overlooked that the part the muscles play in the normal functions of any part of the skeleton is at least as important in the production, development, and maintenance of its normal form as the normal functions are in reference to the force of gravity. It cannot possibly be good treatment to exclude the action of the muscles.
The gymnastic enthusiasts, or more correctly the opponents of the fixation treatment, have therefore by degrees been justified in their view that the drawbacks to the fixation method are so great that the latter cannot in any way be considered suitable routine treatment for all marked scoliosis. This does not imply that the spinal jacket has been permanently banished from spinal treatment; far from it. The adherents of the fixation method of treatment have done much good; various kinds of removable spinal jackets have been produced which are almost as effective as the fixed plaster jacket, and which, since they can be taken off, are no hindrance to the most energetic use of gymnastic treatment. The greatest drawback to the treatment by spinal jackets is therefore almost removed. Thus we have by degrees come to the usual conclusion, after such a struggle, that neither of the two extreme views can be held in the long run, and we find that in the treatment of scoliosis, as of everything else, we attain the best results by using all the means at our disposal. Certain as it is that the fixation treatment carried to excess is unsuitable for the treatment of the slighter forms of scoliosis, it is equally certain that the intelligent use of a well-constructed spinal jacket which can be taken off makes the treatment of the more severe forms more successful and renders the result more permanent.
The position of medical gymnastics in the treatment of scoliosis may, in my opinion, be summarised as follows : -
Medical gymnastic treatment begun as early as possible on the first indications of lateral deviation of the spine certainly prevents the development of the more severe forms in almost all cases. In the case of small school children (about the age of ten or twelve) Ling's medical gymnastics should be sufficient. For older patients and in all cases of well-marked scoliosis one must have recourse to the most energetic and continuous medical gymnastics combined with the use of corrective apparatus, or of apparatus in which the patient lies in a corrected position. Further, such treatment must inevitably be used along with and alternating with the treatment by spinal jackets, which ought to be used in some - relatively few - cases.
Lastly, it must be said that our results are in reality very slight in severe cases with marked deformity of the thorax and bulging of ribs, in spite of the most energetic, varied, and expensive treatment. It is also worthy of mention that energetic efforts to produce mobility in a severe case of scoliosis which has not yet reached its height may under certain conditions be injurious and not beneficial. In certain cases fixation may be regarded as a natural cure, checking further deformity. In unfavourable conditions increase of deformity may be produced by unintelligent attempts to increase mobility. In any case, a gymnast practising alone and not having access to suitable medico-mechanical apparatus is almost helpless, even if he possess the energy of de Ron.
It should be added to these remarks on scoliosis that a new method of treatment for mobility and correction has been recently developed. This method, developed by Klapp in his surgical clinic in Bonn, is based on the observation that four-footed animals bend the spine much more than human beings in walking and running. The method consists of performing certain movements in the four-footed position, which aim strongly at mobility. To what extent this method will come into use in the treatment of scoliosis cannot yet be estimated.
 
Continue to: