The strength of the medical gymnast is, moreover, by no means sufficient. High degrees of scoliosis with definite changes in the soft parts and bones require much greater force for their effective correction. This is true not so much of the momentary force, which can certainly be exercised in sufficient strength manually, but of its staying power. A little reflection indicates that a correcting movement for scoliosis, if it is to have some effect, must be given for a much longer time than purely manual medical gymnastics allows. In scoliosis between the medical gymnastic seances every force tends to send it back to its ordinary degree, or rather to increase it; in these circumstances it is almost incredible that a passive correction performed for a very short time should play any noteworthy curative part. It has some importance in mobilising fixed scolioses; but even here greater force is often necessary.

On the other hand, this first indication, restoration to normal form, can be fulfilled in a much more effective way by using mechanical apparatus and machines. In the last few decades a great variety of corrective apparatus for the treatment of scoliosis has appeared, from the simplest and most primitive, which can be put together with easily-obtained material by any doctor, to the most complicated and expensive mechanical apparatus, which are only to be found in special institutions. By means of these apparatus, arranged for pressure at the ordinary points of application on the thorax and pelvis, and provided with mechanical arrangements so that the point of application as well as the force used can be individualised according to the existing condition almost as much as in the manual corrective movements, the time of correction can be increased according to need. And in this gymnastic exercise scheme for scoliosis, which one sees carried out in large orthopaedic institutes abroad, which scheme may occupy up to eight hours' gymnastic treatment in all every day, the greatest part of this time is devoted to correction in more or less complicated apparatus. The correction takes place in different positions, as lying, sitting, hanging, the inclined plane, etc. With such a corrective treatment it is clear that one can produce a greater effect than by manual correction in one or two Ling gymnastic seances daily; in severe cases the treatment is completed by a bed so constructed that a certain degree of correction takes place even at night.

In using the patient's own muscles to produce correction one may use purely active movements, pure self-corrective exercises. Some of these are to be found in the Ling system of gymnastics (e.g., Spring-sitting Holding, etc.), besides which whole systems have been developed by gymnasts in Germany, and every interested gymnast can think out for a special case specially suitable home exercises. These exercises, which can be done without the simplest apparatus, are specially of importance in those cases in which the patient possesses enough energy to work himself for the correction of his deformity. Such patients are, however, few and far between, as every one who treats scoliosis finds by experience. To make this active correction with the help of the patient's own muscles more effective one gives resistance in all scoliosis movements. It is quite evident that a strong and skilful gymnast can exert with his hands a suitable resistance to active movements which serve to correct and over-correct a scoliosis. It is to be noted, however, that trunk movements require specially strong resistance, and that it is technically much harder to give manual resistance firmly and continuously enough in these than in extremity movements. Experience shows, too, that the gymnast is specially apt to tire in scoliosis treatment, so that the treatment becomes by degrees less energetic. For these reasons I am almost inclined in this form of scoliosis treatment to assign a higher merit to machines than to the Ling gymnastics. In the Zander collection of apparatus we find a whole group of active apparatus bearing upon scoliosis exercises; and outside the Zander system of apparatus, and indeed before it, many kinds of useful and effective apparatus were constructed and used for this special orthopaedic purpose.

The sum total of the foregoing criticism seems to me to be that one can seldom, as has been and is so often done in our own country, recommend the exclusively manual Ling scoliosis gymnastics as the ordinary method for all scoliosis treatment. Its great value, however, cannot be denied in the treatment of young school children with early discovered lateral deviations of slight degree. On the contrary, the manual treatment of these cases, so often practised in our Swedish institutes, cases so slight that their treatment borders on prophylactic therapy, has certainly a very great value as prophylaxis against the development of more severe forms of habitual scoliosis, and my opinion is that the reason we have such a small percentage of severe scoliosis in Sweden is because we treat girls with curvature as early as we do by Ling gymnastics. To mobilise and correct marked cases of scoliosis with a definite degree of fixation mechanical arrangements are, however, absolutely indispensable.

The more strongly and continuously the treatment by all these means is continued the better is the result. Of what nature are the results when one has tried by all these means to mobilise, correct and over-correct, as much as the conditions allow ? In slight cases, the so-called first degree of scoliosis, and in the slighter cases of the second degree, the result may be good enough; in all the more severe cases one must, however, allow that progress, even with the most energetic and, varied treatment, is unsatisfactory. One can assert, broadly speaking, in spite of the arduous work of decades on this subject, that scoliosis treatment still rests at about the same stage as was reported in 1880 by an official English Commission during the heated discussion on scoliosis of that time. The point to determine was which of the two methods of scoliosis treatment (which at that time were sharply opposed to each other), treatment by spinal jackets or by gymnastics, gave the best results. The Commission came to the conclusion that in slight cases something could well be gained by either method, but that in severe cases the aim was attained by neither. If any improvement in the results has been obtained since that time - many statements in the form of reports from different countries to the first International Congress on Physical Therapy held at Liege point to a somewhat less pessimistic Opinion nowadays - it depends, beyond a doubt, on the fact that medico-mechanical gymnastics has become more and more known and used by those who treat scoliosis. All who do so should render homage to one of its greatest exponents, Gustaf Zander, who systematised medico-mechanical gymnastics.