This section is from the book "Eating To Live", by John Janvier Black. Also available from Amazon: Eating to Live.
There is another delicious mushroom not common in the North, but often found in the South, - the Amanita Casarea, or royal agaric. Here the gills, ring, and stalk are yellow, not white, no scales on the stalk, but a bag-like membrane through which the stalk runs. The Deadly Agaric has the umbrella without warts, the gills white, the stalk hollow, with a large ring and a bulb at the ground end, with a bag-like upper margin, and a hollow stalk long and slender. No one can mistake this hollow stalk in any mushroom for the solid stalk of the edible common mushroom after once he has felt and compared them. There are no scales or warts on the common mushroom; then the color of the gills, the general appearance, its standing with head erect, while the hollow-stem ones have a mean, leaning, cast-down look, showing them the villains they are.
The common mushroom often has the umbrella four inches broad; the stalk is stout, round, and smooth below the ring, and not usually as long as the umbrella is broad. The common mushroom has an odor of its own, a woody odor, a raw odor, and so has the Deadly Agaric. The Fly Agaric has little or no odor. All these three - the Fly Agaric, the Deadly Agaric, and the common mushroom - have a taste not unpleasant in the raw state, and unfortunately, when cooked each has a good flavor and not distinctive.
The Horse mushroom, Agaricus Arvensis, looks like the common mushroom, the Agaricus Cam-pestris, but is larger, and is often taken for and eaten for common mushrooms. It is edible and safe. It grows along hedges and in cultivated fields. The umbrella is shining white and the stem is a little hollow. The gills are at first white, a very suspicious quality, but they brown up as it gets older. The ring is double, not single, as in the common mushroom.
There is another common mushroom, an edible one, the Hypholoma Appendiculatum. It grows in clusters around stumps in grass-fields. The color is transparent white, with a purple or brownish tinge when wet. The umbrella is thin and bell-shaped, and the edges roll up somewhat. The gills are a purple brown; it has no ring, and the stalk is hollow.
The Horsetail Fungus, the maned agaric, Co-prinus Comatus, is edible, and grows along the roadside in grass in dense clusters. The umbrella in this species remains closed, not open, and when commencing to decay it rolls outward, and the fungus liquefies in a dark fluid. This is the way it decays. The umbrella is white, with fringy scales. The gills are broad, close to the stalk, and, like the common mushroom, turn from pink to dark. The stalk is long and hollow, and has a ring which can be moved up and down. A few appear in early summer, but it is most plentiful in the fall.
Two other specimens of Coprinus are found, and mostly around walls and houses, - Coprinus Atramentarins. The stalk is short and stout, and it is edible. The color is ashy and dark, and it has no scales, but is furrowed. Coprinus Micaceous is a small one and is edible, with the umbrella light brown or darker. These species are quite common and grow around houses, but I do not think are so palatable as to entail the certain risk the amateur runs in eating them. I think ninety-nine-one-hundredths of the wild mushrooms we eat are the Agaricus Campestris, the common mushroom, and any one can tell them after a little practice. Before eating any other kind I want them passed upon by an expert who has very frequent practice. Our most poisonous species of toadstools have a wrapper, as it were, around the base of the stalk, called a volva; if in addition they have white gills and spores and a bulbous base, they should not be eaten.
The Parasol Fungus, Lepiota Procera, is large and tall, and grows in grass; it is not poisonous, but it is tough and not desirable. It is white or brown. The umbrella is scaly, and the ring is free on the stalk.
The Chanterelle, the Cantharellus Cibarius, grows in the woods in summer. It is yellow and has a crumpled margin. The upper surface is depressed and the gills run down over the stalk. It is not good enough to risk eating it, if gathered by the average hunter.
The Fairy Fungus, Marasmius Oreades, grows in the grassy lawns in rings, which are called fairy rings. It is tough and not good, though edible.
The stalk is tubular, and the umbrella, or pileus, is thin. It is of a drab color; the spores are white.
To determine the color of the spores of a mushroom press it on a piece of white paper and allow it to remain a while, and the color of the spore will be shown.
The tests to distinguish poisonous from non-poisonous mushrooms or toadstools in common vogue, as of cooking a silver spoon with them, the blackening of the spoon being a sign of poison, are utterly unreliable. Cooking in milk or vinegar may do more harm than good if the fungi are poisonous. There are two classes of poisonous fungi, the irritant and the narcotic. The narcotic are the most dangerous. The irritant may work their own cure by causing vomiting soon after they have been eaten. The narcotic may cause serious symptoms after ten or twelve hours through the nerve centres. The irritant fungi, as a rule, have a pungent, disagreeable taste, the narcotic a rather pleasant taste.
Muscarin is the chief poisonous active principle of the Amanita Muscaria. Muscarin is a colorless alkaloid, which forms salts with acids. Muscarin is not poisonous to flies, but this mushroom contains another poison which is volatile and kills flies. Muscarin can be made synthetically by treating Cholin with nitric acid. Poisoning by the fly mushroom comes on in from a half-hour to two hours, up to ten hours. First come colic, vomiting, diarrhoea, then contracted pupils and salivation; then the patient becomes drunk, as from alcohol, the vision is disturbed, and convulsions may supervene; stupor comes on with apoplectic symptoms, and either symptoms of collapse and death follow or the patient gradually recovers from his stupor and recovery takes place. The fatal result is often postponed until the second or third day. As to treatment, evacuate the stomach by emetics or apo-morphine hypodermically; if free vomiting does not take place, use the stomach-pump and give croton-oil to evacuate the bowels. Atropia is the antidote to muscarin; give it hypodermically, combat tendency to heart failure with digitalis, strychnine, etc. Atropia is only a physiological antidote; there is no known chemical antidote to muscarin.
 
Continue to: