This section is from the book "The Law Of Contracts", by Theophilus Parsons. Also available from Amazon: The law of contracts.
The practice of discounting bills or notes, by deducting from their face the interest for the whole time they had to run, began with our banks, and was soon so firmly established, that it was sanctioned by the courts, almost of necessity. But this practice is, in itself, certainly usurious; for the borrower has the use of the amount of the note, minus the interest, and pays interest for the whole amount Having been sanctioned in respect to corporations whose business it was to lend money, a distinction could not be made against individuals who lent money; and it may now be considered as settled, rather for the sake of convenience than upon principle, that it is not usurious to take the interest in advance, by way of discount, although it is obvious, that by carrying this principle far enough, any amount of excessive interest may be taken. Thus, if the legal interest were six per cent., and a note for a thousand dollars had ten years to run, the borrower would receive four hundred dollars, and, at the end of ten years, pay six hundred for the use of it, or sixty dollars a year for the use of four hundred, which is obviously much more than even compound interest There seems, however, to be a strong disposition to limit this practice to short paper, or at least not to apply it to long loans or discounts, although nothing consider a contract for money payable in months, to be payable in calendar months, and to consider a calendar month as the twelfth part of a year, and compute interest accordingly, though they are of different lengths. A note given in February, at two months, will have fifty-seven days to run, and pay 1 per cent. interest, as for the sixth part of a year; but a note given in December, at two months, will nave sixty-two days to run, and pay the same rate of interest. The same difficulty arises in computing interest for a small number of days; and therefore some approximation, which can be made by an easy and practicable mode of computation, if made in good faith, and without being intended as a cover for usury, has been considered allowable, without drawing after it the penalty of the statute. Such being the universal practice, of other persons as well as banks, we think a jury would not be warranted, from the mere fact that the interest thus computed slightly exceeds the legal rate, to infer a corrupt and usurious agreement. And we think the present case comes within this rule. The intent was to compute and receive the interest for sixty days and grace. The grace is a regular portion of the time the note has to run, and the bank had a right to compute and receive interest for it. The period of sixty days is one-sixth of a year, as nearly as can be computed without a fraction; and three days is the nearest approximation to the tenth part of a month, or the 120th part of a year, without fractions of a day. Upon this view of the case, we are of opinion that it is not shown that usurious interest was taken, contrary to the provisions of the statute, and that the defence is not sustained" like a fixed rule or standard can be found, either in the authorities or in the usage, and it must often be difficult to apply such a distinction.(z) It.seems * originally to have been doubted, whether the receipt of interest quarterly or semi-annually was not usurious, on the ground that the lender received thereby more than the legal rate by the year. And for a considerable time those contracts were considered usurious, upon which the legal interest was deducted from the sum loaned, or paid in advance, (a) But the practice is now universal, both in England and in this country. The authorities, however, which sustain this departure from the accurate enforcement of the usury laws, seem mainly to rest upon the principle, that the additional sum received by the lender may be considered in the nature of a compensation for his services and trouble. And all the decisions show, that such anticipated reception of interest must be confined to cases where a bill or note is given by the borrower, and does not extend to any ordinary private agreement of loan, (b)
(z) See Barnes v. Warlich, Cro. Jac. 25, Yelv. 31, and Grysill v. Whichcott, Cro. Car. 283; Caliot v. Walker, 2 Anst. 496; Eaton v. Bell, 5 B. & Ald. 40; Mowry v Bishop, 5 Paige, 98; Marvine v. Hymen, 2 Kern. 223.
(a) In Anonymous, Noy, 171, usury was pleaded to an action upon a bond. Popham, J., said : "If a man lend £100 for a year, and to have £10 for the use of it, if the obligor pays the £10 twenty days before it is due, that does not make the obligation void, because it was not corrupt. But if, upon making the obligation, it had been agreed that the £10 should have been paid within the time, that should have been usury, because he had not the £100 for the whole year, when the £10 was to be paid within the year." And verdict was given accordingly.
(b) In N. Y. Firemen Ins. Co. v. Ely, 2 Cowen, 703, the principle extracted from the cases, by Sutherland, J., in which the whole court seem to have concurred, was this •' " The taking of interest in advance, is allowed for the benefit of trade, although, by allowing it, more than the legal rate of interest is, in fact, taken; that being for the benefit of trade, the instrument discounted, or upon which the interest is taken in advance, must be such as will, and usually does, circulate or pass in the course of trade. It must, therefore, be a negotiable instrument, and payable at no very distant day; for, without these qualities, it will not circulate in the course of trade. Under these limitations, the taking of interest in advance, either by a bank, or incorporated company without banking powers, or an individual, is not usurious." In Marsh v. Martindale, 3 B. & P. 154, the defendants were acceptors of a bill of exchange for £5,000, drawn by Robert Wood, payable in three years, to the plaintiff. It appeared that Robert Wood, having granted an annuity to the plaintiff, which he desired to redeem, ana which, together with charges upon it, was worth £4,134, brought to the plaintiff the bill in question, which the plaintiff agreed to discount, and the £5,000 was made up of the price of the annuity, £4,134, £116 paid to the defendant in cash, and £750, three years' discount on the note. The present action was on a bond given as a substitute for the note, and the defence of usury was set up, which it was attempted to answer by considering the transaction as a discount in advance of the interest due on the £5,000 note, which would not be usurious. The court determined, that as the bill was for so long a time, coupled with its being a redemption of the annuity, it was evident that the transaction was not a discount in the way of trade, but a loan of money, a method of obtaining more than legal interest, which was corrupt in law, whatever the intention of the parties might have been. Lord ALvanley, C. J., said. "It is also con-tended, that at all events, the negotiation of the bill of exchange was a transaction in the usual mode, in which all persons possessed of bills of exchange have been
 
Continue to: