We would now consider the effect of bankruptcies or insolvencies under the laws of foreign nations, as of France or England, for example; and the effect of bankruptcies or insolvencies under our own laws, upon the citizens or subjects of those foreign governments.1

It may be said to be well established, and mainly on the principles and authorities already stated, that the statutory discharge of a debt not made nor to be performed within the State where it is discharged, has no force elsewhere; and that the discharge of a debt in the State in which it was made and is to be performed, * and of which both parties are citizens, is valid everywhere. But if made in one State, to be performed in another, the laws of the first State cannot operate against those of the second, (t)2

(t) See the cases already cited in the notes of the last section. The doctrine of the text is well set forth by Betts, J., delivering the opinion of the court in the matter of Zarega, 4 Law Reporter, 480. " It appears that some of the creditors of the petitioner reside abroad, and the objection taken by the opposing counsel is, that the discharge of the bankrupt under the laws of this country do not discharge him from his creditors residing abroad. The exception is taken under the idea that the debt was contracted in Germany, although I see no evidence before the court to that effect, or anything to show but that the debt was contracted here in the ordinary course of business transactions, such as an order sent abroad for goods, or the like. It is not essential to ascertain the origin or location of the debt. If, however, the debt was contracted in Germany, it might have an effect on the proceedings when the final steps are to be taken. The question here is, whether the discharge of a bankrupt under the law of this country, would operate as a bar to the demands of foreign creditors, it being asserted that the United States have no power to destroy contracts entered into without their jurisdiction, and the contract is to be left to the jurisdiction of that country wherein it originated. It is not important, in disposing of this question, to enter into a discussion of the essence of contracts or their obligations, nor to inquire into the effect of a discharge in this country, under the bankrupt law, if set up in a foreign country as a bar to the claims of creditors. In England, as well as in France and Holland, and perhaps throughout Europe generally, the discharge of a bankrupt, under the laws of either country, operates in all other places whatsoever. So a person having been decreed a bankrupt in France, may avail himself of the privileges it confers on him in any part of England, and plead it with the same effect as in his own country. So in Eng1 A fugitive from justice, who has acquired no domicil elsewhere, may be proceeded . against in bankruptcy, after his flight, in the State where his domicil was. Cobb v. * Rice, 130 Mass. 231. - K.

2 In Phelps v. Borland, 103 N. Y. 406, it was held that an English discharge in bankruptcy was not a defence to an action brought in New York, upon a debt or obligation of the bankrupt, by a citizen who was not a party to, and did not appear in the bankruptcy proceedings, although the debt or obligation was contracted in England and was payable there. May v. Breed, 7 Cush. 15, was disapproved.

But insolvent and bankrupt laws also sequestrate the property of the insolvent at the commencement of proceedings. And it is an important question how far a foreign law can operate in this respect Thus, an Englishman, or an American trader in England, is there a bankrupt, and his assignees become invested with all his rights of property, and take possession of his effects *as far as they can. But he has property in Boston, and a creditor there attaches that property before the assignees take possession; and the question comes up, whether this creditor or his assignees have the better right In other words, Can the Boston creditor receive his whole debt out of the property he has attached, or must that property pass into the general fund, and that creditor take only his dividend?1

It is obvious that the system of bankrupt laws may be regarded in two ways. In one, it would be merely local and municipal. In the other, it would be in some sort a branch of the law of nations. Assuming that all civilized nations have now some kind of insolvent system, it may then be held, that all of these land, where they set up that claim in behalf of their own bankrupts in foreign countries, they allow the same privileges to others. But in this country we do not recognize such a doctrine. A discharge as a bankrupt in a foreign country, is not deemed here a bar to any action that may be brought. The discharge is considered as local; and although an assignee of an individual, declared a bankrupt in a foreign country, would be allowed to sue as such assignee, yet our courts would not recognize the discharge as a bar to debts contracted in this country, or due to citizens of this country." The courts of Pennsylvania seem to have adopted to a considerable extent, the principles of comity which have prevailed in the English courts, and hold, that the same effect shall be given to a discharge in insolvency in another State, which that State gives to discharges in the State of Pennsylvania. Smith v. Brown, 3 Binn. 201; Boggs v. Teackle, 5 id. 332; Walsh v. Nourse, id. 381. But if the debt is both contracted and to be discharged in the foreign State, a discharge there will bind the creditor, even if he be a resident of this country. The cases above cited, and especially Shaw, C. J., in May v. Breed, 7 Cush. 15; Sherrill v. Hopkins, 1 Cowen, 103; Very v. McHenry, 29 Me 206.

1 It has been held in Massachusetts that a court of equity will enjoin one of its citizens who in expectation of the insolvency of his debtor,also a citizen of Massachusetts, makes an attachment of the debtor's property without the State. Dehon v. Foster, 4 Allen, 545; 7 Allen, 57; Cunningham v. Butler, 142 Mass 47. And this does not violate the Constitution of the United States. Cole v. Cunningham, 133 U. S. 107. If, however, the creditor by virtue of such an attachment collects his claim before a bill in equity is brought by the assignees in insolvency to enjoin him, he will not be deprived of his advantage. Lawrence v. Batcheller, 131 Mass 504; Proctor v Nat Bank of Republic, 152 Mass. 223; Batcheller v. Nat. Bank of Republic, 157 Mass. 33. Nor will a Massachusetts creditor be enjoined from prosecuting an attachment abroad if the injunction would not make the property attached available for equal distribution among the creditors. Therefore, if there are attachments by foreign citizens subsequent to that of the Massachusetts citizen, the latter will be allowed to prosecute the attachment suit for his own benefit. Chipman v. Manufacturers' Nat. Bank, 156 Mass. 147. See further, as to the validity of such attachments, 5 Harv. L. Rev. 211.