(/) Gore v. Gibson, 13 M. & W. 623. See ante, p. n. 2

(g) McCrillis v. Bartlett, 8 N. H. 569. See Smith v. Spooner, 3 Pick. 229; Man-son v. Felton, 13 Pick. 206.

(h) Richardson v. Strong, 13 Ired. L. 106; Gore v. Gibson, 13 M. & W. 623 , Niell v. Morley, 9 Ves. 478; McCrillis v. Bartlett, 8 N. H. 569. In Baxter v. The Earl of Portsmouth, 5 B. & C. 170, 2 C. & P. 178, a tradesman supplied a person with goods suited to his station, and afterwards, by an inquisition taken under a commission of lunacy, that person was found to have been lunatic before and at the time when the goods were ordered and supplied. It was held, that this was not a sufficient defence to an action for the price of the goods, the tradesman, at the time when he received the orders and supplied the articles, not having any reason to suppose that the defendant was a lunatic.

(i) Molton v. Camroux, 12 Jur. 800 (1848); S. C. 2 Exch. 487; in error, 4 Exch. 17. See also Niell v. Morley, 9 Ves. 478; Price v. Berrington, 7 E. L. & E. 254; Fitzhugh v. Wilcox, 12 Barb. 235. In Dane v. Kirkwall, 8 C. & P. 679, it was held, that to constitute a defence to an action for use and occupation of a house, taken by the defendant under a written agreement, at a stipulated sum per annum, it is not enough to show that the defendant is a lunatic, and that the house was unnecessary for her; but it must also be shown that the plaintiff knew this, and took advantage of the defendant's situation; and if that be shown, the jury should find for the defendant; and they cannot, on these tarts, find a verdict for the plaintiff for any smaller sum than that specified in the agreement.

1 There has been considerable difference of opinion as to the legal effect of a lunatic's deeds and contracts made when apparently sane. The weight of recent American authority is in accordance with the English decision of Molton v. Camroux above, cited. Thus it is held that the deed of a lunatic given for fair consideration is not void and is voidable only on return of the consideration. Scanlan v. Cobb, 85 Ill. 296; Burnham v. Kidwell, 113 Ill 425; Boyer v. Berryman, 123 Ind. 451; Warfield v. Warfield, 76 Ia. 633; Gribben v. Maxwell, 34 Kan. 8; Rusk v. Fenton, 14 Bush, 490; Evans v. Horan, 52 Md. 602; Fitzgerald v. Reed, 17 Miss. 94: Riggan V. Green, 80 N. C. 236. That a bond and mortgage given by a lunatic for money lent him in good

The statutes of the different States provide that idiots, lunatics, drunkards, and all persons of unsound mind, may be put under guardianship. And the finding by a competent court of the fact of lunacy, and the appointment of a guardian, are held to be conclusive proof of such lunacy, and all subsequent contracts are void. (j) In England, an inquisition is only presumptive

(j) Northwestern Ins. Co. v. Blanken-ship, 94 Ind. 535; Rannells v. Gerner, 80 Mo. 474; Fitzhugh v. Wilcox, 12 Barb. 235; Wadsworth v. Sherman, 14 Barb. 169.

Contra in Pennsylvania, In re Gangwere's Estate, 14 Penn St. 417. In Leonard v. Leonard, 14 Pick. 280, the court said: "It is suggested, on the part of the defaith by one having no knowledge of his insanity may be enforced. Copenrath v. Kienby, 83 Ind 18; Mutual Life Ins. Company v. Hunt, 79 N. Y. 541; Kneed-ler's Appeal, 92 Pa. 428. And see Black's Estate, 132 Pa. 134. Or a note given for value. McCormick v. Littler, 85 Ill. 62 , Shoulters v. Allen, 51 Mich. 529; Lancaster Nat. Bank v. Moore, 78 Pa. 407. And generally if a contract has been made in good faith for full consideration without knowledge or ground for knowledge of the insanity and has been executed, it will be binding. Brodrib v. Brodrib, 56 Cal. 563, 567; Young v. Stevens, 48 N. H. 133; Matthiessen, etc. Co. v. McMahon's Adm. 38 N. J L. 536; Sims v. McLure, 8 Rich. Eq. 286. The limits of a lunatic's liability are shown by decisions holding that information such as would lead a prudent person to suspect the incapacity will avoid the contract, Matthiessen, etc. Co. v. McMahon's Adm. 38 N. J. L. 536, and prevent a recovery for money lent or services rendered. Lincoln v. Buckmaster, 32 Vt. 652; Ricketts v. Jolliff, 62 Miss. 440. But see Leavitt v. Files, 38 Kan 26 That if the contract though executed is not a fair one or a conveyance not for full value, it may be avoided, Riggs v. American Tract Society, 84 N. Y. 330. So if no consideration is received. Van Patton v. Beals, 46 Ia. 62. Or if the consideration is neither necessary or beneficial to the lunatic Physio-Medical College v. Wilkinson, 108 Ind. 314. Where the lunatic has not received, but the party endeavoring to hold or charge him has parted with full value, there is disagreement even among the courts which profess to follow Molton v. Camroux. It is held, on the one hand, that a mortgage given by a wife for money advanced to her husband may be set aside by her heirs, Northwestern Ins. Co. v. Blaukenship, 94 Ind 535; that lack of consideration for the promissory note of a lunatic may be shown against a purchaser for value without notice, Moore v. Hershey, 90 Pa. 196; Wirebach's Exec. v. First Nat. Bank, 97 Pa. 543; and that a lunatic who has made a voluntary conveyance of his property may set the conveyance aside though the grantee subsequently mortgaged the property to an innocent third person. Hull v. Louth, 109 Ind. 315. On the other hand, it has been held that one who purchases land from the grantee of a lunatic in good faith, for value and without notice, obtains a valid title, though the original transaction with the lunatic was not a fair one. Drake v. Crowell, 40 N J. L. 58. And see Valentine v. Hunt, 115 N. Y. 496. And the English Court of Appeals has recently held that insanity is no defence even to a surety, unless it is also shown that the plaintiff was aware of the insanity. Imperial Loan Co. v. Stone, [1892] 1 Q. B. 599.

In a few jurisdictions the deeds and contracts of lunatics are held absolutely void or voidable as against any one and under any circumstances. Thus in Brigham v. Fayerweather, 144 Mass. 48, the devisee of one who after the execution of her will became imbecile was allowed to set aside a mortgage made by her while imbecile. The court said . " It is settled in this Commonwealth that the deed of an insane person is ineffectual to convey a title to land, good against the grantor, or against his heirs and devisees, unless it is confirmed by the grantor himself when of sound mind, or by his legally constituted guardian, or by his heirs or devisees. Valpey v. Rea, 130 Mass. 384, and cases there cited. And such deed may be disaffirmed without returning the consideration money or placing the other party in statu quo. Chandler v. Simmons, 97 Mass. 508, 514, 515. Nor is it material that in taking the deed the grantee acted in good faith, and without knowledge of the grantor's insanity, because he who deals with an insane person, as with an infant, does so at his peril " See also Dexter v. Hall, 15 Wall. 9; Hovey v. Hobson, 53 Me. 451; Rogers v. Blackwell, 49 Mich. 192; Halley v. Troester, 72 Mo. 73; Farley v. Parker, 6 Ore. 105 , Crawford v. Scovell, 94 Pa. 48.