(e) Shepard v. Ward, 8 Wend. 642. And it is a general rule, that payment to one partner is good, and binds the firm. Duff v. The East India Co. 16 Ves. 198; Yandes v. Lefavour, 2 Blackf. 371; Gregg v. James, Breese, 107; Porter v. Taylor, 6 M. & S. 156, Scott v. Trent, 1 Wash. (Va.) 77. Even after dissolution. King v. Smith, 4 C. & P. 108. And see Morse v. Bellows, 7 N. H. 568. So payment to one of two joint creditors it good, although they are not partners in business. Morrow v. Starke, 4 J. J. Marsh. 367.

(f) Offley v. Clay, 2 Scott, N. R. 372.

(g) Spencer v. Tisue, Addis. 316; Seaborne v. Blackston, 2 Freem. 178; Thrasher v. Tuttle, 22 Me. 335.

(h) Offley v. Clay, supra.

(i) Mynn v. Joliffe, 1 Moody & R. 326.

(j) Mynn v. Joliffe, supra; Sykes v. Giles, 5 M. & W. 646.

1 Nor to a person in an attorney's office, who gave a receipt in the attorney's name. O'Connor v. Arnold, 53 Ind. 203.

2 An auctioneer has no authority to receive a check in payment where the terms of sale require payment in cash. Broughton v. Silloway, 114 Mass. 71.

One may be justified in making payments to a party who is sitting in the creditor's counting-room, and apparently intrusted with the transaction of the business, and authorized to receive the money, although he be not so in fact. (k)1 In general it is only a money payment that binds the principal; (l) so that he is not affected by any claim which the debtor may have against the agent. (m) 2 And an agent authorized to receive payment in * money cannot bind his principal by receiving goods, (n) 3 or a bill or note. (o)

Payment by bankers to one of several persons who have jointly deposited money with them, and who are not partners, or to one of several joint trustees, does not discharge the bankers as to the others, unless they had authorized the payment. (p) And pay(k) Barrett v. Deere, Moody & M. 200. And see Wilmot v. Smith, id. 238; Moffat v. Parsons, 5 Taunt. 307. But payment to an apprentice, not in the usual course of the creditor's business, but on a collateral transaction, has been held not to discharge the debt, although made at the creditor's counting-room. Sanderson v. Bell, 2 Cromp. & M. 304.

(l) Thorold v. Smith, 11 Mod. 71.

(m) Thus, where an assured who resided at Plymouth employed an insurance broker in London to recover a loss from the underwriters, and the latter adjusted the loss by setting off in account against it a debt due from him to the underwriters for premiums, and the broker became bankrupt, and never paid the money to the assured, it was held, that the set-off in account between the underwriters and the broker was not payment to the assured, inasmuch as the broker had only authority to receive payment in money. Bartlett v. Pentland, 10 B. ft C. 700.

(n) Howard v. Chapman, 4 C. & P. 508.

(o) Sykes v. Giles, 5 M. & W. 645; Ward v. Evans, 2 Ld. Raym. 028. And see Townsend v. Inglis, Holt, N. P. 278. But quaere whether, in those States where the giving of a negotiable promissory note is regarded as prima facie payment, an agent would not be authorized to receive payment by such bill or note.

(p) Innes v. Stephenson, 1 Moody & R. 145. The depositors here were coassignees of a bankrupt, and the money had been drawn out on the check of two out of three depositors, but the name of one of the two was forged. Lord Tenterden said, "that the case was a very clear one; that money was paid to bankers by three persons not partners in trade; that it had been stated that one of them could draw checks so as to bind the others, but that was not the law, and to allow it would defeat the very object of paying the money in jointly; and it must be well known to the jury that it was not the practice, unless the persons drawing stood in the relation of partners." And see, to the same effect, Stone v. Marsh, Ryan ft M. 864. But this rule as to bankers is peculiar. "It is a general rule," says Mr. Justice Maule, "that a man may pay a debt to one of several persons with whom he has contracted ment to one of two or more joint creditors of a part of the debt, does not so alter the nature of the debt as to permit the other creditors to sue alone for the remainder. (q) But payment to one of several executors is held to be sufficient. (r) Whether payment to one of several assignees of a bankrupt is sufficient, may be doubtful; it seems clear that it is not, if shown to have been against the will of the co-assignees. (s) A voluntary payment by a principal to the assignees * of a bankrupt agent, with a full knowledge of the facts, cannot be recovered back, when the principal so paying subsequently compromises with third parties for the default of his agent. (t) In general a payment to a trustee is effectual against his cestui que trust at law, even in cases where it would be relieved against in equity. (u)

1 A shopman, to receive payment over the counter only, cannot receive it elsewhere. Clark v. Smith, 88 Ill. 298. See Harris v. Simmerman, 81 Ill. 413; Eclipse Windmill Co. v. Thorson, 46 la. 181.

2 See Hogarth v. Wherley, L. R. 10 C. P 630. Delivery of money is in itself evidence of payment of a debt and not of a loan. Downey v. Andrus, 43 Mich. 65. The setting off an agent's debt by a debtor is not payment as against the principal Bevis v. Heflin, 63 Ind. 129; Aultman v. Lee, 43 la. 404.

3 As "wheat" in part payment for a threshing machine as agreed by an agent Aultman v. Lee, 43 la. 404. See Drain v. Doggett, 41 la. 682. Or a "piano," although the principal confirmed the previous act of the same agent in receiving a pipe and a watch and chain. Bertholf v. Quinlan, 68 Ill. 297. Harris v. Simmerman, 81 Ill. 413, held, that the receiving an old safe, taken by an agent in part payment for a new one, which he forwarded, rendered such payment valid.

If one of several plaintiffs, or a nominal plaintiff suing for the benefit of another, discharge the debt by a collusive receipt, without payment of money, a court of law will prevent the defendant jointly. In the case of a banker he cannot do so; but that arises from the particular contract which exists between him and his customer." Husband v. Davis, 10 C. B. 645, 4 Eng. L. & Eq. 342.