This section is from the book "The Law Of Contracts", by Theophilus Parsons. Also available from Amazon: The law of contracts.
2 Or if he opens a negotiation, and his principal completes the sale, he can recover the proper proportion of the commission. Martin v. Silliman, 53 N. Y. 615. See a proper bargain, has been held entitled to his commission although the purchaser refused to take the land from a defect in the title. (rr) And if he makes a contract for the purchase of goods to arrive, he may recover his commissions although the goods do not arrive.(rs) Neither factor nor broker can have any valid claim for his commissions or other compensation if he has not discharged all the duties of the employment which he has undertaken, with proper care and * skill, and entire fidelity.(s) And for his injurious default, he not only loses his claim, but the principal has a claim for damages. (t) He must account for all the profits made from contracts entered into on behalf of his principal.(tt) And if he has stipulated to give his whole time to his employer, he will not be permitted to derive any compensation for services rendered elsewhere. (u) Neither the factor nor broker can acquire any claim by services which are in themselves illegal or immoral, or against public policy. (v)1
A factor to whom goods were sent for sale cannot be sued until after demand or instructions to remit. (vv)
A broker to whom a certificate of shares has been intrusted with special instructions, can make no disposition of them which
(rr) Doty v. Miller, 43 Barb. 529; Middleton v. Findler, 25 Cal. 76; Knap]) v. Wallace, 4 N. Y. 477; Schwartze v. Yearly, 31 Md. 270; Gonzales v. Broad, 57 Cal. 224; contra, Rockwell v. Newton, 44 Conn. 333. See, as to the rights of a ship-broker, Cook v. Fisk, 12 Gray, 491, and Cook v. Welch, 9 Allen, 350.
(rs) Paulsen v. Dallett, 2 Daly, 40.
(s) Denew v. Deverell, 3 Camp. 451; Hamond v. Holiday, 1 C. & P. 384; White v. Chapman, 1 Stark. 113; Hurst v. Holding, 3 Taunt. 32; Dodge v. Tileston, 12 Pick. 328. See also Shaw v. Arden, 9 Bing. 287; Hill v. Featherstonhaugh, 7 Bing. 569; Fisher v. Dynes, 62 Ind. 348. As to his duty to keep accounts, see White v. Lady Lincoln, 8 Ves. 363. He must not confound the principal's property with his own. Lupton v White, 15 Ves. 432. He cannot recover his compensation if he has embezzled the principal's funds, although it exceeds the amount embezzled. Turner v. Robinson, 6 C. & P. 16 n. (g).
(t) See note (b), p. *86.
(tt) Payne v. Waterston, 16 La. An. 239.
(u) Thompson v. Havelock, 1 Camp. 527, and cases cited in note; Massey v. Davies, 2 Ves. Jr. 317; Gardner v. MCutcheon, 4 Beav. 534.
(v) Haines v. Busk, 5 Taunt. 521; Josephs v. Pebber, 3 B. &C. 639; Wyburd v. Stanton, 4 Esp. 179; Buck v. Buck, 1 Camp. 547; and Rex v. Shatton, in note; Armstrong v. Toler, 11 Wheat, 258; Pearce v. Foote, 113 Ill. 228; Whitesides v. Hunt, 97 Ind. 191; Johnson v. Hunt, 81 Ky. 321; Crawford v. Spencer, 92 Mo. 498.
(vv) Wright v. People, 61 Ill. 382; Burns v. Pilsbury. 17 N. H. 66.
Thomas v. Lincoln, 71 Ind. 41, to the effect that a broker can receive a commission only on the actual completion of a sale of personal property. - K.
1 Thus a broker cannot recover premiums paid for illegal insurance, Allkins v. Jupe, 2 C.. P. D. 375; nor money advanced to cover losses in stock-gambling, nor his commissions therein Fareira v Gabell, 89 Penn. St. 89. But a broker carrying stocks on a margin, is entitled to his expenditures, especially where he informs his principal frequently of the State of his accounts, and the latter, knowing the custom, makes no objection until called upon to pay. Robinson v. Norris, 51 How. Pr 442. - K.
these instructions do not permit; nor can evidence of a contrary usage be received;1 and if he does this, he is liable for what was the market price of the shares on the day when he violated his instructions. (vw)
A commission merchant cannot detain proceeds of a sale from his principal, in favor of claims or equities between a third party and the principal, in which the commission merchant has no interest. (vx)
(vw) Parsons v. Martin, 11 Gray, 111. (vx) Aubery v. Fiske, 36 N. Y. 47.
1 As to the admissibility of evidence of usage, see Robinson v. Mollett, L. R. 7 H. L. 802; Perry v. Barnett, 15 Q. B. D. 388; Irwin v. Williar, 110 U. S. 499, 513; Bailey v. Bensley, 87 Ill. 556; Commonwealth v. Cooper, 130 Mass. 285.
 
Continue to: