2 A promise or acknowledgment to a person other than the creditor is ineffectual. Fort Scott v. Hickman, 112 U. S. 150, 161; Biddel v. Brizzolana, 64 Cal. 354, Collar

Tenterden's act, by implication, required that the acknowledgment should be to the creditor himself. (h) But this cannot be the legitimate effect of the statute, if, as has been said, and would seem to be deducible from the words of the statute, its purpose is merely to substitute "the certain evidence of a writing, signed by the party chargeable, for the insecure and precarious testimouy to be derived from the memory of * witnesses, "(i) For then, a writing so signed, should have the whole force of an acknowledgment proved by witnesses before the statute. Perhaps it might be admitted, from the peculiar nature of negotiable paper, that an acknowledgment by the maker to the payee, would remove the bar of the statute, in favor of a subsequent party to the note. This, however, is not quite certain on the authorities(j) There seems to be no reason why a part payment or acknowledgment to an agent, should not relieve a debt from the statute as to his principal, (k) or that one to an administrator should not defeat the statute as to his claim in behalf of the intestate's estate.(l)