We know not why a ship may not be mortgaged in the same way and to the same effect as a personal chattel. Such mortgages of ships are not unfrequently made. They should now be registered under the requirements of the Statute of 1850. (l) Some uncertainty perhaps exists, as yet, as to the effect and operation of this statute, when it conflicts with or covers the same ground as a State statute. The decisions on this question, so far as they have arisen, are not quite reconcilable. Where a statute of the United States, on a subject which is clearly within the power of Congress, conflicts with a State statute, we should have no doubt that it superseded the State statute. But if it only covers the same ground and is not inconsistent with it, either of two views might be entertained as to its effect. One would be, that it should be held as cumulative to the State statute, both statutes remaining in full force. The other would be, that where the statute of the United States covers the whole ground, it renders the State statute unnecessary and nugatory, and in fact repeals it. We think the tendency of adjudication and of practice favors this last view. Therefore, a registry of a mortgage of a ship under the act of 1850, would make the mortgage valid, although it was not recorded in the manner required by State statutes in relation to mortgages of personal chattels. (m)

(j) Hudson v. Gustier, 4 Cranch, 393; Sawyer v. Maine Ins. Co. 12 Maes. 291; The Mary, 9 Cranch, 126; Bradstreet v. Neptune Ins. Co. 8 Sumner, 607; The Flad Oyen, 1 Boh. Adm. 185.

(k) The Flad Oyen, 1 Boh. Adm. 185; The Kierlighett, 3 Boh. Adm. 06; Havelock v. Rockwood, 8 T. B. 268; Wheel, wright v. Depeyster, 1 Johns. 471.

(l) C. 27, 9 U. S. Stats, at Large, 440. In respect to the place where a mortgage should be recorded, see ante, p. * 265, n. (v).

(m) See Sinnot v. Davenport, 22 How 227.