(j) See ante, vol. i. p. * 117.

(k) Wilson v. Burr, 25 Wend. 386; Stevens v. Adams, 23 id. 57; Newman v at law for his services; (l) but a "medical practitioner," whose legal appellation is usually "apothecary," has; but we have no such distinction here. (m)

Where there is a special agreement for the performance of work, no action can be maintained on a quantum meruit while the contract remains open and executory. (n) It often happens, where there is a contract for a piece

Washington, Mart. & Y. 79. And see Van Atta v. McKinney, 1 Harrison, 235. An attorney has, in some states, a lien upon his client's papers left with him, for any general balance due him. Dennett v. Cutts, 11 N. H. 163; Walker v. Sargeant, 14 Vt. 247; Aliter in Pennsylvania. Walton v. Dickerson, 7 Penn. St. 376. So by statute in many states he has a lien upon a judgment actually recovered in favor of his client, for his fees and disbursements. Duncklee v. Locke, 13 Mass. 525 ; Potter v. Mayo, 3 Greenl. 34; Gammon v. Chandler, 30 Me. 152; Ocean Ins. Co. v. Rider, 22 Pick. 210; Hobson p. Watson, 34 Me. 20. And even without statute provisions. Sexton v. Pike, 8 Eng. (Ark.) 193. A counsel, who, with his client's consent, withdraws from a case after having tendered beneficial services, does not thereby lose his right to compensation for the services rendered, unless at the time of his withdrawal he waives or abandons his claim to compensation. Coopwood v. Wallace, 12 Ala. 790.

(l) Chorley v. Bolcot, 4 T. R. 317; Lipscombe v. Holmes, 2 Camp. 441; Toucher v. Norman, 3 B. & C. 745. Neither could a physician, who prepared or dispensed his own medicines, recover for them, although they were furnished to his own patients. Best, J., in Allison p. Haydon, 1 Mo. & P. 591; s. c. 4 Bing. 619.

(m) In some states physicians may recover for their services, although they were never licensed as physicians. See Towle v. Marrett, 3 Greenl. 22; Hewitt v. Wilcox, 1 Met. 154; Bailey v. More, 4 Denio, 60; Warren v. Saxby, 12 Vt. 146. In other states there either now exist, or have existed, statutes providing, that they shall not be entitled to the benefit of the law to recover their fees, unless they have been duly licensed by some medical society, or graduated a doctor in some medical school. See Hewitt v. Charier, 16 Pick. 353; Spaulding v. Al-ford, 1 id. 33; Smith v. Tracy, 2 Hall, 465 ; Berry v. Scott, 2 Har. & G. 92. In some states it has been held, that although such restrictive statutes have been repealed, a physician cannot recover for services performed before such repeal. Warren v. Saxby, 12 Vt. 146; Nichols v. Poulson, 6 Ohio, 305; Bailey v. Mogg, 4 Denio, 60; contra, Hewitt v. Wilcox, 1 Met. 154. A physician undertakes to employ usual skill, but not to cure. Gallaher v. Thompson, Wright, 466. He may, however, make a conditional contract, that if he does not cure he shall not be paid; such a contract is valid; and in such case he cannot recover for his services or his medicines, unless he shows a performance of the condition on his part. Smith v. Hyde, 19 Vt. 54. It is not necessary, however, in order to constitute such a conditional contract, that a specific price should be agreed upon. In case of a cure he will be entitled to a reasonable compensation. Mock v. Kelly, 3 Ala. 387.

(n) Clark v. Smith, 14 Johns. 326; Rees v. Lines, 8 C. & P. 126; which was an action of assumpsit. The first count of the declaration was on a special agreement for the plaintiff to build a house for the defendant, at an agreed price, and stated that the plaintiff had bestowed work upon the house, and that the defendant abandoned the contract, and hindered the plaintiff from completing it; 2d count, for goods sold. Pleas, non-assumpsit, and that the defendant did not abandon the contract, or prevent the plaintiff from completing the house. The particulars of demand were for work and materials under the agreement. Held, that if the defendant had not hindered the plaintiff from completing the house, the plaintiff could not recover any thing, except for extra work, which was not in the contract; and that the fact that the defendant, when asked for money, had said that he would never pay a farthing, was no proof that the contract had been abandoned, as the defendant was not then liable to pay any thing, the work not being completed. - So where A engaged to convey away certain rubbish for B at a specified sum, under a fraudulent representation by B as to the quantity of rubbish which was to be so conveyed. Held, that in an action for the of work to be done for a definite sum, as for a house to be built or repaired, that extra work is done by the party employed; and there are numerous and conflicting cases as to the rights and obligations of the parties in these cases. It seems to have been at one time doubted whether any claim existed for such extra work, unless a new contract could be shown; and such is the provision of the French law. (o) But from the authorities generally, and the reason of the case, we think the following principles may be deduced. The party cannot recover for extra work, or even for better materials used, if he had not the authority of the other party therefor. (p) But the authority will be implied if the employing party saw or knew of the work or materials in time to object and stop the work, without injury to himself, and not under circumstances to justify his belief that no charge was intended, - and did not object, but received and held the benefit of the same. (q) And if he received from the work actually done, A could recover only according to the terms of the special contract, although when he discovered the fraud he might have repudiated the contract, and sued B for deceit. Selway v. Fogg, 5 M. & W. 83. If the whole of such special contract is executed on the plaintiff's part, and the time of payment has elapsed, general assumpsit may be maintained; and the measure of damages will be the rate of compensation fixed by the special contract. Bank of Columbia v. Patterson, 7 Cranch, 299; Perkins v. Hart, 11 Wheat. 237; Chesapeake and Ohio Canal v. Knapp, 9 Pet. 541; Baker v. Corey, 19 Pick. 496.