This section is from the book "The Law Of Contracts", by Theophilus Parsons. Also available from Amazon: The law of contracts.
Many cases have arisen where the effect of alterations in the property insured is considered. The general rule must be, that mere alterations, although important and extensive, do not of themselves discharge the insurers. But they would have this effect if expressly prohibited, because they would then be a breach of warranty; and they would have this effect, although not expressly prohibited, if they materially increased the risk. (v)
If the alterations, when completed, did not increase the risk, but the process of making them subjected the property while it was going on to an increased risk, we should say that the insurers would be discharged, if the property was burned by reason of that increased risk, but not if the property was burned during the time of that increased risk, but from a totally independent cause.
It cannot be doubted, however, that the insured may have the right, under many circumstances, of increasing the risk during the policy, and subjecting the insurers to that increase of risk. Thus, when a dwelling-house was insured, and, as a part of the condition and circumstances of the property in the description thereof, a store was described as belonging to the same owner, and near the dwelling-house, and the store burned down, and the owner rebuilt it, and in the rebuilding it took fire, and the dwelling-house caught from it and was destroyed, the insurers were not discharged. (w)
(u) Pearson v. Commercial Ass. Co. 15 C. B. (N. S.) 804.
(v) See Young v. Washington Co. Ins. Co. 14 Barb. 645; Calvert v. Hamilton Ins. Co. 1 Allen, 308, and cases infra.
1 Pearson v. Commercial Ass. Co. supra, was affirmed in the Exchequer Chamber in L. R. 8 C. P. 548, and in the House of Lords in 1 App. Cas. 498. See Wingate v. Foster, 8 Q. B. D. 582. "While loading at B." was declared to cover the period while the vessel was at B. for the purpose of loading, whether she was actually engaged in loading or not, in Reed v. Merchants' Ins. Co. 95 U. S. 23; and "Port risk," to cover a vessel while in port before leaving her wharf to begin her voyage, in Nelson v. Sun Ins. Co. 71 N. Y. 458.
We have no doubt that the same rule would apply to the making of proper or necessary repairs; and the insured would have a right to make them without affecting his policy. (x) l Indeed, policies now not unfrequently give to the insured the right of making repairs. And it is obvious that it would generally be for the interest of the insurers, that the building should be kept in good repair. The failure of the insured to repair a defect in the building arising after the contract is made, does not prevent the assured from recovering, unless he was guilty of gross negligence. (y) It would always be safest, however, when important repairs are contemplated, to give notice to the insurance company of such intention. And we think that an unreasonable refusal on their part to allow such repairs would not enlarge their defence.
It is held that a covenant against alteration is broken, and the insurers discharged, although the alteration is made by a tenant of the insured without his knowledge. (yy)
 
Continue to: