Where the vessel or cargo is lost, but a valuable part remains in the owner's hands, or comes to him afterwards, either by salvors, or by a restoration of seized property, this cannot be called an actual total loss. Formerly, it was the practice to adjust it as a partial loss, the insured giving the insurers credit for whatever thus came into their possession. It was found, however, to be more convenient, and on the whole more just to * treat it as a total loss; and to consider all the property recovered as belonging to the insurers. (x) This is now the usual practice. Such a loss is called a constructive total loss, or a technical total loss.

(v) See Roax v. Salvador, 3 Bing. N. C. 266; Hogg v. Augusta Ins. Co. 7 How. 605; Murray v. Hatch, 6 Mass. 466; Tudor v. New England Ins. Co. 12 Cush. 554. The word salvage has been defined to mean "a part or remnant of the subject insured which survives a total loss."

The insurers are not, therefore, entitled to property as salvage, which was severed from the voyage by their consent, before the loss took place. Mutual Ins. Co. v. Munro, 7 Gray, 246.

(w) Walker v. Protection Ins. Co. 20 Maine, 317.

The property saved does not, however, belong to the insurers, unless they pay for a total loss, or unless the owner transferred it to them. (y) This transfer the owner makes, by what is called in insurance law an Abandonment. And when he has a right to make this abandonment, and makes it at the right time and in the right way, he thereby changes an actual partial loss into a constructive total loss.

No one topic of the law of insurance has been more fertile of difficult questions, than the law of abandonment. These questions are, in general, When has the insured the right of abandonment? In what way must he exercise this right? What is the effect of abandonment? and What is the effect of withholding abandonment?

The policy sometimes provides that there shall be no abandonment. This would be intended, undoubtedly, to prevent a partial loss from being made a constructive total loss, and would probably have the same effect as if the policy expressly provided that there should be no constructive total loss. (z) 1

Much more frequently the phrase is "against total loss only." This, or any equivalent language, would, of course, exclude all liability for a partial loss. The question still remains, however, whether the phrase "total loss," thus used, means only actual total loss, or includes constructive total loss. We are disposed to think that the better reasons and the weight of authority would exclude from such a policy a constructive total loss. It has not, however, been always so held. (a)

(x) There is a difference of opinion as to the expediency of extending the right of abandonment. Some authorities are in favor of restraining the right. See Mitchell 9. Edie, 1 T. R. 615; Deblois v. Ocean Ins. Co. 16 Pick. 303; Bainbridge v. Neilson, 10 East, 343. But see the remarks of Story, J., in Peele v. Merchants Ins. Co. 3 Mason. 38.

(y) The insured may always withhold an abandonment if he chooses, and have his loss adjusted as a partial loss merely. Smith v. Manuf. Ins. Co. 7 Met 461; Hamilton v. Mendes, 2 Burr. 1211.

(z) See Barney v. Maryland Ins. Co. 5 Harris & J. 138.

1 That the power of abandonment will not be taken from the insured without express words, was declared in Forwood v. No. Wales Ins. Co. 9 Q. B. D. 732.

* As the purpose and effect of abandonment are to make a legal transfer to the insurers of the property abandoned, no person can make this abandonment if he never had the power to make this transfer, or if at the time of abandonment he had lost this power by his own voluntary act, or by a peril not insured against. (b) This exception does not apply where the ship is lost by a sale from necessity. (c) And if a wrecked ship be abandoned, and after the abandonment the master sells the ship, the sale will be considered as a sale of the property of the underwriters, the master then being and acting as their agent from necessity. (d)

It is always best, and is always usual, when a claim is made for a total loss, to make an abandonment. It may not be necessary, however, to make one where a wrecked ship ceases to be a ship, and becomes, to use a phrase of Lord Tenterden, "a mere congeries of planks;" (e) or if the ship has not been heard from for a sufficiently long time. (f) l

Where the property insured has passed from the persons insured, by a sale made necessary by a peril insured against, it may

(a) Until quite recently the authorities have almost uniformly held that the words "total loss only" or "partial loss excepted," or any similar phrase, excluded a constructive total loss. See Cocking v. Fraser, Park, Ins. 151; Thompson v. Royal Exch. Ass. Co. 16 East, 214; Navone v. Haddon, 9 C. B. 30; Hugg v. Augusta Ins. Co. 7 How. 595; Korean v. U. S. Ins. Co. 1 Wheat. 219; Biays v. Chesapeake Ins. Co. 7 Crunch, 415; Saltus v. Ocean Ins. Co. 14 Johns. 145; Humphreys v. Union Ins. Co. 3 Mason, 429; Depeyster v. Sun Ins. Co. 17 Barb. 306, 19 N. Y. 272; Williams v. Kennebec Ins. Co. 31 Me. 461; Robinson v. Commonwealth Ins. Co. 3 Sumner, 220; Murray v. Hatch, 6 Mass. 465; Buchanan v. Ocean Ins. Co. 6 Cowen, 831. In Heebner v. Eagle Ins. Co. 10 Gray, 131, where a vessel was insured against "total loss only," the court held, that the insured could recover for a constructive total loss. And in Kettell v.

Alliance Ins. Co. 10 Gray, 144, where insurance was effected on tin plates, "partial loss excepted," the same rule was applied. We consider these cases as directly opposed to the current of authority in this country. For a full discussion of this question, see 2 Parsons, Mar. Law, 338, note 2.

(b) Higginson v. Dall, 18 Mass. 96; Rice v. Homer, 12 Mass. 230; Gordon v. Mass. Ins. Co. 2 Pick. 249; Smith v. Columbia Ins. Co. 17 Penn. State, 253; Bidwell v. North Western Ins. Co. 19 N. T. 179; Williams v. Smith, 2 Caines, 13; Allen v. Commercial Ins. Co. 1 Gray, 154.