Sec 468

But while the statutes are to be applied to all loans, they are not to be stretched to extend to any transactions but loans.7 They do not cover, therefore, annuities;8 nor guarantees;9 nor bottomry bonds;10 nor partnership adventures;11 nor bona fide sales of securities, no matter at what discount.12 sec 469. A court of equity will enjoin the collection of any-Borrower thing beyond the amount of the loan with legal interest.13 But a borrower on a usurious contract cannot, in equity, have the transaction set aside unless he offer to repay to the lender whatever is actually due on the loan with legal interest.14 But he in usurious contract cannot defend without doing equity.

Statutes do not apply to any transactions but loans.

1 Archer v. McCray, 59 Ga. 546; Wilkinson v. Wooten, 59 Ga. 584; King v. Ins. Co., 57 Ala. 118.

2 Lee v. Cass, 1 Taunt. 511; Scott v. Lloyd, 9 Pet. 440; Huling v. Drexel, 7 Watts, 126; Gray v. Brackenridge, 2 Pen. & W. 75; Beadle v. Munson, 30 Conn. 175.

3 Large v. Passmore, 5 S. & R. 51; Grubb v. Brooks, 47 Penn. St. 485.

4 Bevan ex parte, 9 Ves. 223; Eaton v. Bell, 5 B. & Al. 34; Wilcox v. How-land, 23 Pick. 167.

5 Eagle Bank v. Rigney, 33 N. Y. 613; Eaton v. Bell, 5 B. & Al. 34; Wilcox v. Howland, 23 Pick. 167.

6 Campbell v. Sloan, 62 Penn. St. 481.

7 See Easterlin v. Rylander, 59 Ga. 292.

8 Lawley v. Hooper, 3 Atk. 273.

9 Larnego v. Gould, 2 Burr. 715.

10 Long v. Wharton, 3 Keb. 304; see Jennings v. Ins. Co., 4 Binn. 244.

11 Huston v. Moorhead, 7 Barr, 45.

12 Wycoff v. Longhead, 2 Dall. 92; Gaul v. Willis, 26 Perm. St. 259; Ful-wiler v. Jackson, 1 Phila. 145.

13 Duquesne Bank's App., 74 Penn. St. 426.

14 1 Story Eq. Jur. 12th ed. sec 301; Mason v. Gardiner, 4 Bro. C. C. 436; may reclaim the excess paid over principal and legal interest.1 - A lender on a usurious contract is precluded from suing as much in equity as in law, when barred by statute.2 "If the lender," says Judge Story, "comes into a court of equity seeking to enforce the contract, the court will refuse any assistance and repudiate the contract.3 But, on the other hand, if the borrower come into a court of equity, seeking relief against the usurious contract, the only terms upon which the court will interfere are, that the plaintiff will pay the defendant what is really and bona fide due to him, deducting the usurious interest;4 and if the plaintiff do not make such an offer in his bill, the defendant may demur to it, and the bill be dismissed.5 The ground of this distinction is, that a court of equity is not positively bound to interfere in such cases by an active exertion of its powers; but it has a discretion on the subject, and may prescribe the terms of its interference; and he who seeks equity at its hands may well be required to do equity. . . . But, in the other case, if equity should relieve the lender, who is plaintiff, it would be aiding a wrong-doer, who is seeking to make the court the means of carrying into effect a transaction manifestly wrong and illegal in itself."6 "And, upon the like principles, if the borrower has paid the money upon a usurious contract, courts of equity (and, indeed, courts of law also) will assist him to recover back the excess paid beyond principal and lawful.

Hindle v. O'Brien, 1 Taunt. 413; Ben-field v. Solomons, 9 Ves. 84; Rogers v. Rathbun, 1 John. Ch. 367; Fanning v. Dunham, 5 John. Ch. 142; Williams v. Fitzhugh, 37 N. Y. 444; Whitehead v. Peck, 1 Kelly, 140; Ballinger v. Edwards, 4 Ired. Eq. 449; Sporrer v. Eifler, 1 Heisk. 633. See Ahern v. Goodspeed, 72 N. Y. 108; Powers v. Chaplain, 30 N. J. Eq. 17; Lee v. Stiger, 30 N. J. Eq. 610.

1 Browning v. Morris, 2 Cowp. 792; Bond v. Hays, 12 Mass. 36; Thomas v. Shoemaker, 6 W. & S. 179; Heath v. Page, 48 Penn. St. 130; Hopkins v. West, 83 Penn. St. 109.

2 Fanning v. Dunham, 5 John. Ch. 142.

3 Fanning v. Dunham, 5 John. Ch. 142.

4 Williams v. Fitzhugh, 37 N. Y. 444; Whitehead v. Peck, 1 Kelly, 140; Ballinger v. Edwards, 4 Ired. Eq. 449.

5 Mason v. Gardiner, 4 Bro. Ch. 436; Rogers v. Rathbun, 1 John. Ch. 367; Fanning v. Dunham, 5 John. Ch. 142; Ware v. Thompson, 2 Beasl. N. J. 66; Ruddell v. Ambler, 18 Ark. 369; Noble v. Walker, 32 Ala. 456.

6 Story Eq. Jur. 12th ed. sec 301.

interest; but not further. So, the borrower may maintain a bill to compel the giving up of securities left as collateral security for a usurious debt, although he might have a defence in an action at law."1 - Under the Pennsylvania statute, the reservation of an illegal rate of interest does not prevent the recovery of the amount actually loaned with legal interest.2 But under the act of congress, a national bank, by reserving usurious interest on a loan, forfeits the entire interest, but not the principal.3