Story Case

Mrs. Mary Story, the wife of Amos Story, carelessly drove her horses and wagon into a vehicle belonging to John Moore, doing damage to the vehicle and also injuring Moore. Mr. Story was not with his wife at the time of the collision. Mrs. Story refused to pay anything for the losses suffered by Moore and the latter brought suit against her to recover damages. Mrs. Story's defense was that Moore could not sue her alone, but must bring his action jointly against herself and husband. Moore relied upon a statute, which provided that the husband need not be joined in an action when the wrong was committed independently by the wife. Was the suit properly started?

Ruling Court Case. Leipf Vs. Strause, Volume 101 Alabama Reports, Page 433; Volume 46 American State Reports, Page

122; Volume 23 Lawyers' Reports, Annotated, Page 622.

The defendant brought this action for injuries sustained by the plaintiff from a vicious dog kept by the defendant and which was known to be vicious and yet allowed to run at large. In defense the defendant contended that she was a married woman, that her husband was still living, and that she was living with him at that time, and that he was liable for the wrong; and, if not liable, at least should have been joined in the action. The plaintiff relied upon a statute which provided that the husband need not be joined in any action against his wife for civil wrongs, unless he participated in the wrong.

Mr. Chief Justice Stone said: "Under the common law, if the tort was committed in the presence of her husband, prima facie, it was not her tort, but was presumed to have been the work of her husband's coercion. For such act, unless it was affirmatively shown that she acted independently of her husband's will, she could not be sued, even co-jointly with her husband. It was his tort, and his alone, and he alone was suable for it. If she committed a tort in the absence of her husband, or if present, if it was affirmatively shown that she acted of her own will and independently of his, then she could be sued, but the suit could only be maintained against her and her husband jointly.

"In this last class of cases the statutes have been changed to such an extent that it is neither proper nor permissible to join the husband as a defendant in an action for a tort committed by his wife, 'in the commission of which the husband does not participate'. In cases involving a tort by the wife in which at common law the husband and wife should be jointly sued, the wife, under the statute, may and must be sued alone." Accordingly it was held that the wife might be sued alone since it was not shown that the husband joined in the commission of this tort.

Ruling Law. Story Case Answer

At common law a married woman who committed a civil wrong or tort at the request or direction of the husband, made the husband alone responsible and he had to be sued alone therefor. If the wrong was committed in his presence, it was presumed to have been done at his request and under his direction; and unless he could show that she acted of her own free will and accord he alone was liable therefor, and the wife could not be joined. If, however, the wife committed a wrong in his absence, or if she committed a wrong in his presence, and he could show that she acted independently, it was their joint wrong, and they had to be sued jointly. He would be responsible for the judgment when entered against them.

In modern statutes many changes have been made in this regard. In cases where husband and wife both participate in the commission of the wrong, both are jointly liable as at common law. But where the wrong was committed by the wife acting independently of her husband, it is generally provided that the wife, and the wife alone, may be sued in respect thereto. In the Story Case, the statute given by the plaintiff, Moore, is applicable, although the wife was doing an errand for her husband. The wrong committed was done independently of the husband. He could be sued separately as a principal since his wife was acting as his agent. This point is taken up in the law of agency.