This section is from the book "Business Law - Case Method", by William Kixmiller, William H. Spencer. See also: Business Law: Text and Cases.
Andrew McElroy of Boston sent a note for collection to the First National Bank of that city, against a person living in Cambridge, Massachusetts, a town contiguous to Boston. The First National Bank sent the note to a small bank in Cambridge to present to the debtor. This was done by the Cambridge bank, and the debtor paid the amount due. Before the remittance was made by the Cambridge bank it became insolvent, and as a result McElroy never received what was due to him. He brought suit against the Boston bank on the ground that the latter had no authority to delegate its authority to collect. The Boston bank defended on the ground that it had not been careless, and although it could have sent its own collector to Cambridge, it had followed the usual custom in appointing another bank to collect. Is this defense good?
Upon the trial of this it appeared that McGiloray held two notes payable to himself. He indorsed them in blank and delivered them to an expressman, with directions to collect them in the ordinary way. This carrier did a great deal of collecting for patrons. Sometimes he collected by personally calling upon the debtor; and sometimes by depositing them in a bank for collection. He did not inform McGiloray how he intended to collect the notes, and was not aware whether they knew that he ever collected notes through banks.
However, he deposited the notes with the Appleton Bank for collection. On the following day he was informed that payment had been made, and the proceeds of the two notes was delivered to the carrier, who in turn delivered it to his principal McGiloray. Through some clerical error, these two notes had been entered as paid, when in fact they had not been. The Apple-ton Bank sues the defendant, claiming to recover money paid under a mistake of fact. The defendant contended that there was no liability because their agent had no authority to delegate his power to collect the notes.
Justice Bigelow delivered the opinion.
Plaintiff is entitled to recover the money so paid although it is the general rule that an agent may not delegate his authority. Where it is customary to do so, it may be done. It is a well established usage for banks to collect. It is their principal business, and in such a case non-delegation of power does not apply.
The authority which an agent exercises is delegated. Now it is a fundamental principle of law that one who exercises delegated power cannot in turn delegate it to some one else. It naturally occurs to one that if the principal consents there is no objection to the creation of a sub-agency. However, if the duties of the agent are purely ministerial, which involve no discretion and no personal skill, then an agent may delegate the doing of them to a sub-agent, unless he has been forbidden to do so by its principal. Therefore, the agent's power can only be delegated if the power is merely ministerial, or if the principal consents. The principal is assumed to consent where delegation is a matter of custom.
In the Story Case, the defense of the Boston bank is good. The bank forwarded this note for collection in the usual course of business to its correspondent. This was an established custom and forms part of the powers of the agent in appointing a sub-agent.
 
Continue to: